Skip to content
VJ Classes

One place to learn science, commerce, arts, computers and life skills

Almost everyone accepts human rights in principle. So why do thoughtful people disagree so sharply about them in practice? Because rights sometimes collide with each other or with public interests, and reasonable people weigh them differently.

Why rights collide

Free speech can clash with a person’s dignity. Liberty can clash with security. Religious freedom can clash with equality. Law uses two tools: reasonable restrictions written into the Constitution, and proportionality. In the privacy case (Puttaswamy, 2017), the Supreme Court said an action that limits a right must pass three tests: legality (it rests on a valid law), legitimate aim (it serves a real public purpose) and proportionality (the means suit the aim and go no further than needed).

Testing a restriction

After violent clashes, a district orders all internet services shut for three days. Legality: is there a law that allows the order? Aim: preventing violence is a legitimate aim. Proportionality: could a narrower step work, and is the order limited in area and time and open to review? In Anuradha Bhasin v Union of India (2020), the Supreme Court held that freedom of speech and the freedom to carry on trade through the internet are constitutionally protected, and that shutdown orders must be proportionate, limited in time and open to judicial review.

Four debates, two sides each

Each debate below gives the main arguments on both sides. Your task is to weigh them, not to take ours.

1. The death penalty

  • One view: For the gravest crimes, it delivers justice to victims and deters others. In Bachan Singh v State of Punjab (1980), the Supreme Court upheld it but limited it to the “rarest of rare” cases.
  • Another view: The right to life is the most basic right; a death sentence cannot be undone if a court errs; evidence that it deters better than life imprisonment is weak. The Law Commission’s 262nd Report (2015) recommended abolishing it for all crimes except terrorism-related offences.

2. Free speech, security and hate speech

  • One view: Democracy needs open criticism, and vague laws make people afraid to speak. In Shreya Singhal (2015), a vague provision was struck down. In 2022 the Supreme Court put the sedition law (Section 124A of the IPC) on hold.
  • Another view: Speech that incites violence or targets groups damages dignity and public order, and the State must act against real threats. The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (in force from 1 July 2024) has no section called sedition but Section 152 punishes acts endangering the sovereignty, unity and integrity of India. Supporters say it targets real threats; critics say it is as broad as the old law.

3. Privacy, technology and welfare

  • One view: Digital identity and data systems, such as Aadhaar, reduce leakage in welfare schemes and help fight crime. In 2018 the Supreme Court upheld Aadhaar for welfare benefits, with limits on its use.
  • Another view: Large databases allow profiling and surveillance, and a failed authentication can shut a poor person out of benefits. The Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 gives individuals rights over their data. The government says exemptions for State agencies are needed for security and public order; critics say they are too broad.

4. A Uniform Civil Code (Article 44)

  • One view: One family law for all would advance equality and gender justice. In Shayara Bano (2017), the Supreme Court held instant triple talaq unconstitutional.
  • Another view: Articles 25 to 29 protect religious freedom and culture, India is diverse, and reform should come through consultation and from within communities, not by imposing one code. In 2018 the Law Commission said a uniform code was neither necessary nor desirable “at this stage”, and in 2023 a new Law Commission invited public views. Goa has had a common family-law code since Portuguese times, and Uttarakhand passed a state law in 2024.

Putting it all together

Rights have three layers: international (UDHR, covenants and treaties), constitutional (Parts III and IV) and statutory (special laws and bodies). Courts and commissions connect them to real life.

If this happensA first step
Someone is held without being produced before a magistrateApproach the magistrate or lawyer; a habeas corpus petition in the High Court
A public servant violates your rightsComplain to the NHRC or the State Human Rights Commission
Sexual harassment at workThe Internal Committee of the workplace
A child is in dangerChildline (1098) or the police
You cannot afford a lawyerThe District Legal Services Authority

Keep learning

These topics appear in civil services, judiciary, UGC NET and law-entrance exams, and in careers in law, public service, journalism, social work, research and teaching. Read Parts III and IV of the Constitution itself, follow summaries of Supreme Court judgments, and read NHRC and UN reports. Mark three dates: 26 November (Constitution Day), 12 October (NHRC’s foundation) and 10 December (Human Rights Day).

Key points

  • Rights can conflict; courts test limits by legality, legitimate aim and proportionality.
  • On each current debate (death penalty, speech and security, privacy and technology, a Uniform Civil Code) serious arguments exist on both sides.
  • Rights work on three layers: international law, the Constitution and special statutes with their bodies.
  • Practical routes include the police and magistrates, High Courts, commissions, legal aid and helplines.
  • Learning to state both sides fairly is a core skill in human rights work.

Download all the notes of this course (PDF)