Skip to content
VJ Classes

One place to learn science, commerce, arts, computers and life skills

A right that nobody can enforce is only a promise. So what can you actually do when your right is violated? In India the first answer is: go to a court.

The route to the courts

Article 32 gives every person the right to move the Supreme Court to enforce a Fundamental Right. This right is itself a Fundamental Right, and Dr Ambedkar called it “the very soul of the Constitution and the very heart of it”. The Court may issue “directions, orders or writs”. A writ is a formal written order of a court.

Article 226 gives the High Courts a similar power, and a wider one: they can issue writs to enforce Fundamental Rights and also “for any other purpose”, such as correcting an illegal official action. In practice many people go to the High Court first.

Courts can also order compensation. In Rudul Sah v State of Bihar (1983), the Supreme Court ordered the State to pay a man who had been kept in jail for years after a court had acquitted him.

The five writs

WritMeaning in LatinWhat it does
Habeas corpus“You may have the body”Orders that a detained person be brought before the court, so that it can decide whether the detention is lawful
Mandamus“We command”Orders a public authority to perform a public duty that it has refused or neglected
Prohibition“To forbid”Orders a lower court or tribunal to stop acting beyond its powers while a case is going on
Certiorari“To be certified”Quashes an order already made by a lower body that acted without power or broke the rules of fair hearing
Quo warranto“By what authority”Challenges a person’s right to hold a public office

Habeas corpus can be asked for by a relative or friend of the detained person, and it can be used against illegal confinement by a private person too. Mandamus does not normally lie against a private individual.

Which writ?

  1. Rekha’s brother was taken by the police three days ago and has not been shown to a magistrate. Habeas corpus.
  2. A government office refuses to decide a pension claim although the law says it must. Mandamus.
  3. A person who lacks the qualification required by law is appointed principal of a government college. Quo warranto.

Prohibition and certiorari

These two are often confused. Prohibition means “stop”: it is issued while proceedings are still going on. Certiorari means “undo”: it is issued after the lower body has made its order.

Public interest litigation

The old rule of locus standi said that only the person whose own right was violated could go to court. But the people most likely to suffer abuse, such as prisoners, bonded labourers or the very poor, often cannot write a petition or pay a lawyer. In the late 1970s and 1980s, judges such as Justice P. N. Bhagwati and Justice V. R. Krishna Iyer relaxed the rule. A public-spirited person or group may now approach the court on behalf of people who cannot. This is public interest litigation (PIL).

In PIL the court may treat a letter or postcard as a petition, take notice of a news report on its own (suo motu), appoint commissioners to inspect a place, and issue continuing directions. Some landmarks:

  • Hussainara Khatoon v State of Bihar (1979): after newspaper reports on undertrial prisoners who had waited in Bihar jails for years, the Court held that speedy trial is part of Article 21 and ordered many releases.
  • Bandhua Mukti Morcha v Union of India (1984): a petition for bonded labourers in stone quarries led to orders for their identification and release.
  • M. C. Mehta cases: a long series on pollution, including the Ganga and Delhi’s air.
  • Vishaka (1997) on sexual harassment at work, and D. K. Basu v State of West Bengal (1997), which set rules for police on arrest and detention.
  • PUCL v Union of India (from 2001): orders that made mid-day meals in government primary schools a legal entitlement.

Is PIL a blessing or a burden?

Supporters say PIL opened the courtroom to the poor and filled gaps where governments failed to act. Critics say some petitions are filed for publicity, that courts have taken on tasks of policy and administration that belong to elected governments and experts, and that continuing orders are hard to monitor. The Supreme Court itself has warned against misuse; it now looks at whether the petitioner acts in good faith and may impose costs on frivolous petitions. Both sides have a point: the same tool that freed bonded labourers can also be used carelessly.

A letter petition

A newspaper reports that a government hostel for tribal girls in a district has had no safe drinking water for months. List four things a letter to the High Court should state.

Answer: who is affected; what is happening and since when; which authority is responsible; and what remedy is sought, such as an inspection and repairs. Enclosing the news report helps.

Other roads to justice

Courts are not the only door. Article 39A directs the State to provide free legal aid, and the Legal Services Authorities Act 1987 created legal services authorities that give free legal help to eligible groups, among them women, children, members of Scheduled Castes and Tribes, persons in custody, persons with disabilities, industrial workers and people below an income limit. Lok Adalats help settle disputes by agreement. Commissions such as the NHRC, covered next, offer simpler remedies.

Key points

  • Article 32 (Supreme Court) and Article 226 (High Courts) let people enforce rights by writs; Article 226 is wider.
  • The five writs are habeas corpus, mandamus, prohibition, certiorari and quo warranto, each for a different kind of wrong.
  • PIL relaxed locus standi so that anyone acting in good faith can seek justice for those who cannot approach the court.
  • PIL has produced landmark rights judgments, but critics warn of misuse and judicial overreach.
  • Free legal aid and Lok Adalats help ordinary people reach justice.

Download all the notes of this course (PDF)