← Human Rights Essentials: From the UDHR to the Indian Constitution

To keep these notes as a PDF, press "Download PDF" and choose "Save as PDF" as the printer. On a phone: open the browser menu, tap Share or Print, then Save as PDF.

VJ Classes

Course notes

Human Rights Essentials: From the UDHR to the Indian Constitution

Understand what human rights are, how the UN and the Indian Constitution protect them, and how courts and commissions make them real.

What you will learn

Contents

Ideas and International Law

Lesson 1What Are Human Rights?

Suppose the police pick up a man at night, keep him in a lock-up for a week and tell nobody. When his family asks, the officer shrugs: “I am the law here.” Something feels badly wrong. But what exactly is wrong, and who says so?

That feeling is where this subject begins. Human rights exist to answer one question: what does every person deserve simply because they are a human being, and who must respect it?

What a human right is

Human rights are the basic rights and freedoms that belong to every person from birth, whatever their nationality, religion, caste, gender, language, wealth or opinions. They protect human dignity, which means the equal worth of every individual.

Three ideas sit inside this definition.

  • They belong to you because you are human. No government, employer or community gives them as a favour, so none can claim to switch them off at will.
  • Someone has a duty. Every right has a right-holder (you) and a duty-bearer (the one who must act or hold back). The main duty-bearer is the State: the government, police, courts and public officials. Employers and others also have duties under law.
  • They need backing. A right written on paper means little without laws, courts and institutions that make it real. Most of this course is about that backing.

Three terms are often mixed up, so keep them apart.

TermMeaningExample
Human rightsClaims of every person, recognised in international documentsFreedom from torture
Fundamental rightsRights guaranteed by a country’s constitution and enforceable in courtArticles 14 to 32 in India
Legal rightsAny right created by a lawA tenant’s right under a rent law

The groups overlap. Many human rights are also fundamental rights in India, but not all of them, and many legal rights are not human rights at all.

Spot the right

Read each situation and ask: which right is at stake, and who must act?

SituationRight at stakeWho must act
A girl is stopped from going to school because she is a girlEducation and equal treatmentThe State, and the school and family under law
A man is arrested and not told whyLiberty and a fair procedurePolice and magistrates
A factory owner threatens workers who try to form a unionFreedom of associationThe State, by making and enforcing labour laws

In each case the right exists because of the person’s humanity, but it is protected only when an institution acts.

The main features of human rights

The United Nations describes human rights with a few key words.

  • Universal: they apply to every human being in every country.
  • Inalienable: they cannot be given up or taken away. Some can be limited by fair legal process. A court can send a convicted person to prison, which limits liberty, but the State cannot jail someone at will.
  • Indivisible and interdependent: no right is “less important”, and the rights support each other. A hungry child finds it hard to learn, and a person who cannot read finds it hard to use the freedom of speech.
  • Equal and non-discriminatory: nobody may be denied a right because of race, sex, religion, caste, birth or similar grounds.

Not all rights work in the same way. A few are absolute: freedom from torture can never be limited, even in war or emergency. Most others, such as freedom of speech or of movement, may be limited by a clear law for a good reason, such as public order, if the limit is necessary and proportionate. How such limits are judged is a theme of later lessons.

Where the idea comes from

The belief that every person has worth is old. In the 3rd century BCE the emperor Ashoka’s inscriptions urged kindness to people and respect for the sects of others. Many traditions in India and elsewhere taught that rulers must protect, not abuse, their people.

The modern language of rights grew step by step in Europe and America.

  • Magna Carta (1215): English barons forced King John to accept that even the king was bound by law.
  • English Bill of Rights (1689): limited the Crown’s powers and protected certain freedoms.
  • Natural rights thinkers such as John Locke argued in the 1600s that people have rights to life, liberty and property that come before any government.
  • American Declaration of Independence (1776): said that all men are “endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights”.
  • French Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen (1789): announced that men “are born and remain free and equal in rights”.

These documents were powerful but incomplete. They often left out women, enslaved people and colonised peoples, and reformers and freedom fighters later turned their ideals against those very exclusions.

The great turning point was the Second World War, with its genocide and mass killing. The UN Charter of 1945 pledged to “reaffirm faith in fundamental human rights, in the dignity and worth of the human person”. In 1948 the UN adopted the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the subject of the next lesson.

India’s road to rights

Indian ideas of rights grew from reform and the freedom struggle. Raja Ram Mohan Roy campaigned against sati, which was banned in 1829. Jyotirao and Savitribai Phule opened schools for girls and for oppressed castes. In 1927 Dr B. R. Ambedkar led the Mahad satyagraha so that people treated as “untouchable” could draw water from a public tank. The Motilal Nehru Report (1928) and the Karachi Resolution of the Indian National Congress (1931) both demanded guaranteed fundamental rights. The Constituent Assembly (1946 to 1949) turned these demands into Part III of the Constitution, which came into force on 26 January 1950.

Key points

  • Human rights are claims that belong to every person because they are human, and they protect human dignity.
  • They are universal, inalienable, indivisible and non-discriminatory; a few are absolute, most can be limited only by fair law.
  • Every right has a duty-bearer, mainly the State, and becomes real only when laws and institutions back it.
  • Human rights (international), fundamental rights (constitutional) and legal rights (any law) overlap but are not the same.
  • The modern idea grew over centuries and entered international law after the Second World War.

Lesson 2The Universal Declaration of Human Rights, 1948

On 10 December 1948, in a hall in Paris, the General Assembly of the United Nations voted on a document that tried to answer a huge question: can the whole world agree on a list of rights that belong to every human being? The result was the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, or UDHR.

How the UDHR was made

The UN was founded in 1945 and soon set up a Commission on Human Rights, chaired by Eleanor Roosevelt, widow of the US President Franklin D. Roosevelt. Its members came from different regions and traditions, among them René Cassin of France, Charles Malik of Lebanon, P. C. Chang of China and John Humphrey of Canada, who headed the UN’s human rights office.

India took part too. Hansa Mehta, who was also a member of India’s Constituent Assembly, is credited with insisting that Article 1 say “all human beings” instead of “all men”.

The General Assembly adopted the Declaration with 48 votes in favour, none against and 8 abstentions. India voted in favour. Each year 10 December is observed as Human Rights Day.

What the Declaration contains

The UDHR has a preamble and 30 articles, which can be read in six groups.

ArticlesThemeExamples
1 and 2Basic principlesAll human beings are born free and equal in dignity and rights; no distinction of race, sex, religion or birth
3 to 11Personal and legal rightsLife, liberty and security; no slavery or torture; equality before law; no arbitrary arrest; fair trial; presumption of innocence
12 to 17Rights in societyPrivacy; movement; asylum; nationality; family; property
18 to 21Freedoms and political rightsThought, conscience and religion; expression; assembly; taking part in government and free elections
22 to 27Economic, social and cultural rightsSocial security; work and equal pay; rest; adequate living standard; education; cultural life
28 to 30Order and limitsA social order where rights can be realised; duties to the community; rights cannot be used to destroy other rights

Two features stand out. First, the Declaration lists civil and political rights (such as a fair trial) alongside economic, social and cultural rights (such as education). The drafters saw them as parts of one whole. Second, it speaks of duties as well as rights: Article 29 says everyone has duties to the community.

Which article?

Match each situation to the most relevant article of the UDHR.

  1. A journalist is jailed for criticising a local official.
  2. A village has no school within reach, and many children drop out.
  3. A woman is paid less than a man for the same job.

Answers: (1) Article 19, freedom of opinion and expression, and Article 9 if the arrest was arbitrary. (2) Article 26, the right to education. (3) Article 23, which includes equal pay for equal work, read with Article 2 on non-discrimination.

Is the Declaration law?

The UDHR is a declaration: a resolution of the General Assembly that states shared principles. It is not a treaty, so by itself it creates no legal duty that can be enforced against a state. Yet its influence has been very large.

  • It became the base for later binding treaties, above all the two covenants of 1966 (next lesson).
  • It inspired national constitutions, laws and court judgments in many countries.
  • Many scholars argue that some of its principles, such as the ban on torture and slavery, now form part of customary international law, which binds every state. Others are more cautious and say only some rights have reached that status.

Critics have raised fair questions. Some argue that the Declaration reflected mainly Western ideas of the individual, and that when it was written many Asian and African peoples were still under colonial rule and could not take part. Defenders reply that the drafters came from many cultures, that the text includes economic, social and cultural rights, and that states from every region have since accepted its principles, for example at the World Conference on Human Rights in Vienna in 1993. Both views deserve a hearing.

India and the UDHR

India’s Constitution was being completed in the same years. The Constituent Assembly adopted it on 26 November 1949, less than a year after the UDHR. The two documents share a post-war faith in dignity, equality and freedom, although the Indian Constitution drew mainly on India’s own freedom struggle. Indian courts have often referred to the UDHR. In the privacy judgment of 2017 (Justice K. S. Puttaswamy v Union of India), the Supreme Court cited Article 12 of the UDHR on privacy.

Key points

  • The UDHR was adopted by the UN General Assembly on 10 December 1948 (Human Rights Day), with no country voting against.
  • It has a preamble and 30 articles covering civil, political, economic, social and cultural rights, and also mentions duties.
  • It is a declaration, not a treaty, so it is not binding by itself, but it is the foundation of later treaties.
  • Some of its principles are widely seen as customary international law; scholars differ on how many.
  • Critics call it Western in outlook; defenders point to its varied authorship and wide later acceptance.

Lesson 3The UN Covenants and Human Rights Treaties

If the UDHR is only a declaration, how do human rights become legal duties that a state cannot ignore? The answer is the treaty.

From declaration to treaty

A treaty, also called a covenant or convention, is a written agreement between states. A state that ratifies it, or joins later by accession, becomes legally bound under international law. Merely signing shows intention; the duty begins on ratification or accession.

After 1948 the UN set out to turn the UDHR into binding law. The Cold War divided the world over which rights mattered most: Western states stressed civil and political rights, while the Soviet bloc and many newly independent states stressed economic and social rights. The outcome was two covenants, adopted by the General Assembly on 16 December 1966 and in force from 1976:

  • the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR)
  • the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR)

With the UDHR they form the International Bill of Human Rights. India became a party to both in 1979, with some declarations and reservations.

ICCPRICESCR
Main rightsLife; no torture or slavery; liberty and fair trial; privacy; religion; expression; assembly; voting; minority rightsWork and fair conditions; trade unions; social security; adequate living standard; health; education; cultural life
Duty of the stateRespect and ensure the rights, largely at onceTake steps, using maximum available resources, towards full realisation (progressive realisation)
Monitoring bodyHuman Rights CommitteeCommittee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights

In a genuine public emergency the ICCPR allows a state to limit some rights, but never the ban on torture and slavery or freedom of thought, conscience and religion.

Declaration, covenant, convention, protocol

These words are not the same. A declaration states principles and is not binding by itself. A covenant or convention is a binding treaty for the states that join. A protocol is an extra agreement attached to a treaty, for example one that creates a complaint procedure for individuals.

Other core treaties

The UN has adopted treaties on particular problems or groups.

TreatyAdoptedProtectsIndia
ICERD1965Against racial discriminationParty since 1968
CEDAW1979Against discrimination against womenParty since 1993
CAT1984Against torture and cruel treatmentSigned 1997, not ratified
CRC1989Rights of childrenParty since 1992
CRPD2006Rights of persons with disabilitiesParty since 2007

Each treaty has a committee of independent experts. States send periodic reports, and the committee responds with recommendations. Some treaties also let individuals complain to the committee, but only against states that have accepted that procedure separately.

How treaties work in India

An international treaty does not automatically become Indian law. Parliament must pass a law to give it effect; Article 253 of the Constitution gives Parliament the power to do so. Article 51(c) tells the State to “foster respect for international law and treaty obligations”. Where Indian law is silent and there is no conflict, courts may use international norms to fill the gap.

Vishaka and CEDAW

In 1997, in Vishaka v State of Rajasthan, the Supreme Court found a gap: India had no law on sexual harassment at the workplace. The Court read Articles 14, 15, 19 and 21 of the Constitution together with CEDAW and laid down guidelines that employers had to follow until Parliament made a law. Parliament passed the Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace Act in 2013.

Duties of the state, and three generations of rights

Treaty bodies describe three levels of duty for the State: to respect (not violate the right itself), to protect (stop others from violating it) and to fulfil (take positive steps to make it real).

The right to education

  • Respect: the State does not bar a child from school because of caste or religion.
  • Protect: the State stops an employer or a family from pulling a child out of school to work.
  • Fulfil: the State builds schools, appoints teachers and provides books and meals.

Writers often sort rights into three generations: first, civil and political rights; second, economic, social and cultural rights; third, “solidarity” rights such as development, peace and a healthy environment. The labels describe history, not rank. At Vienna in 1993 states declared all human rights universal, indivisible, interdependent and interrelated. In 2022 the UN General Assembly recognised the right to a clean, healthy and sustainable environment.

The UN also works through the Human Rights Council in Geneva (47 states, created in 2006), the Universal Periodic Review, in which every UN member state’s record is examined in regular cycles, and the Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights. Europe, the Americas and Africa have regional human rights systems; Asia has no region-wide court.

Key points

  • A treaty binds the states that ratify or accede to it; a declaration states principles only.
  • The ICCPR (civil and political) and the ICESCR (economic, social and cultural) were adopted in 1966, took effect in 1976, and India joined both in 1979.
  • Civil and political duties are largely immediate; economic and social duties are met by progressive realisation.
  • Other core treaties include ICERD, CEDAW, CAT, CRC and CRPD; in India a treaty needs a law of Parliament to operate, though courts use treaty norms to fill gaps.
  • States must respect, protect and fulfil rights.

Rights in the Indian Constitution

Lesson 4Fundamental Rights: Part III of the Constitution

What can you demand from the State in India, and what happens if it says no? The Constitution answers in Part III, Articles 12 to 35, the chapter on Fundamental Rights.

Fundamental Rights at a glance

Fundamental Rights are the basic rights that the Constitution itself guarantees. They are justiciable, which means a court can enforce them. The framers had lived under colonial laws that allowed arbitrary arrest and press censorship, so they wanted rights that no ordinary law or government could brush aside.

Two articles set the ground rules. Article 12 defines “the State” to include the Government and Parliament of India, the governments and legislatures of the States, and local and other authorities. Fundamental Rights are claimed mainly against the State. Article 13 says a law that goes against a Fundamental Right is void to the extent of the conflict.

GroupArticlesMain content
Right to Equality14 to 18Equality before law; no discrimination; equal opportunity in public jobs; end of untouchability and titles
Right to Freedom19 to 22Six freedoms; protection in criminal cases; life and personal liberty; education; safeguards on arrest
Right against Exploitation23 and 24No trafficking or forced labour; no child under 14 in factories, mines or hazardous work
Right to Freedom of Religion25 to 28Conscience and the right to practise, profess and propagate religion; managing religious affairs
Cultural and Educational Rights29 and 30Protection of language, script and culture; minorities’ educational institutions
Right to Constitutional Remedies32Going to the Supreme Court to enforce rights

Some rights belong only to citizens, such as the freedoms in Article 19, the rule against discrimination in Article 15 and equality in public jobs under Article 16. Others, such as Articles 14, 20 and 21, protect every person on Indian soil, including foreigners.

Property is no longer a Fundamental Right. The 44th Amendment (1978) removed it, and Article 300A now says that no person shall be deprived of property except by authority of law.

Equality and freedom in detail

  • Article 14: everyone is equal before the law and has the equal protection of the laws. Equal does not mean identical: a law giving maternity leave only to women is a sensible classification, not discrimination. Courts also treat arbitrary State action as a breach of Article 14.
  • Article 15: the State may not discriminate only on grounds of religion, race, caste, sex or place of birth. Shops, restaurants, wells and public places must be open to all. Special provisions for women, children and disadvantaged groups are allowed.
  • Article 17: untouchability is abolished and its practice in any form is forbidden.
  • Article 19(1): six freedoms: speech and expression; peaceful assembly without arms; forming associations, unions or co-operative societies; moving freely throughout India; living in any part of India; and practising any profession or business. Each is subject to reasonable restrictions. Speech, for example, may be restricted to protect the sovereignty and integrity of India, the security of the State, public order, decency or morality, and against contempt of court, defamation and incitement to an offence.
  • Article 20: no punishment under a law made after the act, no second punishment for the same offence, and no compulsion to be a witness against oneself.
  • Article 22: an arrested person must be told the grounds of arrest, may consult a lawyer, and must be produced before a magistrate within 24 hours, not counting travel time.

Is this post protected?

A college student posts a cartoon online mocking a local MLA’s promises, and the police threaten arrest. Reason in three steps.

  1. Is it speech? Yes. Article 19(1)(a) covers expression, including online posts.
  2. Is there a valid law restricting it? A restriction needs a law and must fall under a ground listed in Article 19(2), such as defamation or incitement to an offence.
  3. Is the restriction reasonable? Courts ask whether it goes further than necessary. Criticism of those in power is the heart of free speech, but a false statement that harms someone’s reputation may be defamation.

In Shreya Singhal v Union of India (2015), the Supreme Court struck down Section 66A of the Information Technology Act because its vague words threatened lawful speech.

Article 21: the expanding right

Article 21 says: “No person shall be deprived of his life or personal liberty except according to procedure established by law.” At first the Supreme Court read this narrowly (A. K. Gopalan, 1950): any procedure laid down by a law was enough. In Maneka Gandhi v Union of India (1978) the Court changed course. It held that the procedure must be fair, just and reasonable, and that Articles 14, 19 and 21 work together.

Since then “life” has meant more than staying alive. Courts have read into Article 21 the right to live with dignity, the right to livelihood (Olga Tellis, 1985), speedy trial (Hussainara Khatoon, 1979), a clean environment, health care, free legal aid and privacy (Puttaswamy, 2017). Education was added expressly as Article 21A by the 86th Amendment (2002): free and compulsory education for children aged 6 to 14.

Limits, emergencies and the basic structure

Parliament can amend the Constitution under Article 368, but in Kesavananda Bharati v State of Kerala (1973) the Court held that it cannot destroy the Constitution’s basic structure, and Fundamental Rights are central to that structure.

The lesson of the Emergency

During a national Emergency, the President may suspend the right to move the courts for most Fundamental Rights. In ADM Jabalpur v Shivkant Shukla (1976), the majority of the Supreme Court held that no one could go to court to enforce Article 21 during the Emergency; Justice H. R. Khanna dissented. The 44th Amendment (1978) then made Articles 20 and 21 impossible to suspend, and in the privacy judgment of 2017 the Court said that ADM Jabalpur was wrongly decided.

Key points

  • Part III (Articles 12 to 35) gives six groups of Fundamental Rights, enforceable in court; a law that violates them is void under Article 13.
  • Equality (14 to 18), freedom (19 to 22), against exploitation (23 and 24), religion (25 to 28), cultural and educational rights (29 and 30) and constitutional remedies (32).
  • The freedoms of Article 19 are subject to reasonable restrictions, which courts can review.
  • Article 21 has grown from a narrow guarantee into the source of dignity, livelihood, privacy and fair-trial rights.
  • Some rights are for citizens only, others for all persons; property is now only a constitutional right under Article 300A.

Lesson 5Directive Principles and Fundamental Duties

The Constitution promises liberty and equality. Does it also promise food, work and a decent life, and if so, why can you not take the State to court when it fails to deliver? The answer lies in Part IV, the Directive Principles.

Directive Principles of State Policy

The Directive Principles of State Policy (DPSP) are in Part IV, Articles 36 to 51. They are directions to the Union and State governments about the kind of laws and policies they should make. The idea was borrowed from the Irish Constitution.

Article 37 says they are not enforceable by any court, yet they are “fundamental in the governance of the country” and it is the State’s duty to apply them in making laws. The framers knew that a poor, newly independent country could not guarantee everything at once, so they wrote a programme. Its aim was social and economic democracy. In his closing speech to the Constituent Assembly on 25 November 1949, Dr Ambedkar warned that India was entering “a life of contradictions”: equality in politics but inequality in social and economic life. The Directive Principles were meant to narrow that gap.

Scholars group the principles into three families. These labels are not in the text.

FamilyExamples
Socialist (welfare)Art 38: promote welfare and reduce inequality; Art 39: adequate livelihood, equal pay for equal work for men and women; Art 41: work, education and public assistance; Art 42: humane conditions of work, maternity relief; Art 43: living wage
GandhianArt 40: village panchayats; Art 43: cottage industries; Art 46: education and economic interests of Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and weaker sections; Art 47: raising nutrition and public health, and prohibiting harmful drinks and drugs
Liberal-intellectualArt 44: uniform civil code; Art 45: early childhood care and education; Art 48A: protecting the environment, forests and wildlife; Art 50: separating the judiciary from the executive; Art 51: international peace and respect for international law

From principles to reality

Directive Principles become real in two ways. Parliament and State legislatures pass laws: the 73rd Amendment (1992) gave constitutional status to panchayats (Article 40); the Right to Education Act (2009) followed Article 21A; the Environment (Protection) Act (1986) draws on Article 48A. And courts read them into Article 21: in Olga Tellis v Bombay Municipal Corporation (1985), the Supreme Court held that the right to livelihood is part of the right to life, supported by Articles 39(a) and 41.

From principle to entitlement

Article 41 asks the State, within its means, to make provision for the right to work. In 2005 Parliament passed the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act, which created a legal right for rural households to ask for wage work. Article 47 makes raising nutrition and public health a primary duty, and the National Food Security Act (2013) gave a legal entitlement to subsidised foodgrains to a large share of the population. In both cases a principle that no court could enforce directly became a law that people could claim.

Fundamental Rights and Directive Principles: a changing balance

In State of Madras v Champakam Dorairajan (1951), the Court held that when the two conflict, Fundamental Rights prevail. Parliament later tried to give some Directive Principles priority, through the 25th and 42nd Amendments. In Minerva Mills v Union of India (1980) the Supreme Court held that the Constitution rests on a balance between Part III and Part IV, and that giving either absolute priority would destroy that balance. Today courts try to harmonise the two.

“Non-justiciable” does not mean “unimportant”

You cannot sue the State merely because it has not carried out a Directive Principle. But Article 37 makes them fundamental in governance, courts use them to interpret rights and to uphold laws that advance them, and Parliament turns them into entitlements.

Fundamental Duties

Part IVA, Article 51A, was added by the 42nd Amendment (1976), on the recommendation of the Swaran Singh Committee. It began with ten duties; an eleventh was added in 2002. Citizens are to:

  • respect the Constitution, the National Flag and the National Anthem;
  • cherish the ideals of the freedom struggle and defend the country;
  • promote harmony and brotherhood across religious, linguistic and regional differences, and renounce practices that insult the dignity of women;
  • value the nation’s heritage and protect the natural environment;
  • develop scientific temper, humanism and the spirit of inquiry;
  • safeguard public property, give up violence and strive for excellence.

The eleventh duty asks a parent or guardian to provide opportunities for education to a child aged 6 to 14. Fundamental Duties carry no penalty in the Constitution itself, but courts have used them, for example the environmental duty, when interpreting laws.

Views differ on their value. Supporters say duties remind citizens that rights live in a community, an idea close to Gandhi’s belief that rights grow out of duty well done, and echoed in Article 29 of the UDHR. Critics reply that a person’s rights should never depend on performing duties, and that vague duties could be used against dissent. Both arguments have been made in Parliament and in the courts.

Key points

  • Directive Principles (Part IV, Articles 36 to 51) guide the State towards social and economic democracy; Article 37 makes them non-justiciable but fundamental in governance.
  • They are often grouped as socialist, Gandhian and liberal-intellectual.
  • They become real through laws such as the Right to Education Act, MGNREGA and the National Food Security Act, and through courts reading them into Article 21.
  • Minerva Mills (1980) holds that the Constitution rests on a balance between Fundamental Rights and Directive Principles.
  • Fundamental Duties (Article 51A, from 1976, eleven in number) are not directly enforceable; their value is debated.

Lesson 6Courts and Rights: Writs and Public Interest Litigation

A right that nobody can enforce is only a promise. So what can you actually do when your right is violated? In India the first answer is: go to a court.

The route to the courts

Article 32 gives every person the right to move the Supreme Court to enforce a Fundamental Right. This right is itself a Fundamental Right, and Dr Ambedkar called it “the very soul of the Constitution and the very heart of it”. The Court may issue “directions, orders or writs”. A writ is a formal written order of a court.

Article 226 gives the High Courts a similar power, and a wider one: they can issue writs to enforce Fundamental Rights and also “for any other purpose”, such as correcting an illegal official action. In practice many people go to the High Court first.

Courts can also order compensation. In Rudul Sah v State of Bihar (1983), the Supreme Court ordered the State to pay a man who had been kept in jail for years after a court had acquitted him.

The five writs

WritMeaning in LatinWhat it does
Habeas corpus“You may have the body”Orders that a detained person be brought before the court, so that it can decide whether the detention is lawful
Mandamus“We command”Orders a public authority to perform a public duty that it has refused or neglected
Prohibition“To forbid”Orders a lower court or tribunal to stop acting beyond its powers while a case is going on
Certiorari“To be certified”Quashes an order already made by a lower body that acted without power or broke the rules of fair hearing
Quo warranto“By what authority”Challenges a person’s right to hold a public office

Habeas corpus can be asked for by a relative or friend of the detained person, and it can be used against illegal confinement by a private person too. Mandamus does not normally lie against a private individual.

Which writ?

  1. Rekha’s brother was taken by the police three days ago and has not been shown to a magistrate. Habeas corpus.
  2. A government office refuses to decide a pension claim although the law says it must. Mandamus.
  3. A person who lacks the qualification required by law is appointed principal of a government college. Quo warranto.

Prohibition and certiorari

These two are often confused. Prohibition means “stop”: it is issued while proceedings are still going on. Certiorari means “undo”: it is issued after the lower body has made its order.

Public interest litigation

The old rule of locus standi said that only the person whose own right was violated could go to court. But the people most likely to suffer abuse, such as prisoners, bonded labourers or the very poor, often cannot write a petition or pay a lawyer. In the late 1970s and 1980s, judges such as Justice P. N. Bhagwati and Justice V. R. Krishna Iyer relaxed the rule. A public-spirited person or group may now approach the court on behalf of people who cannot. This is public interest litigation (PIL).

In PIL the court may treat a letter or postcard as a petition, take notice of a news report on its own (suo motu), appoint commissioners to inspect a place, and issue continuing directions. Some landmarks:

  • Hussainara Khatoon v State of Bihar (1979): after newspaper reports on undertrial prisoners who had waited in Bihar jails for years, the Court held that speedy trial is part of Article 21 and ordered many releases.
  • Bandhua Mukti Morcha v Union of India (1984): a petition for bonded labourers in stone quarries led to orders for their identification and release.
  • M. C. Mehta cases: a long series on pollution, including the Ganga and Delhi’s air.
  • Vishaka (1997) on sexual harassment at work, and D. K. Basu v State of West Bengal (1997), which set rules for police on arrest and detention.
  • PUCL v Union of India (from 2001): orders that made mid-day meals in government primary schools a legal entitlement.

Is PIL a blessing or a burden?

Supporters say PIL opened the courtroom to the poor and filled gaps where governments failed to act. Critics say some petitions are filed for publicity, that courts have taken on tasks of policy and administration that belong to elected governments and experts, and that continuing orders are hard to monitor. The Supreme Court itself has warned against misuse; it now looks at whether the petitioner acts in good faith and may impose costs on frivolous petitions. Both sides have a point: the same tool that freed bonded labourers can also be used carelessly.

A letter petition

A newspaper reports that a government hostel for tribal girls in a district has had no safe drinking water for months. List four things a letter to the High Court should state.

Answer: who is affected; what is happening and since when; which authority is responsible; and what remedy is sought, such as an inspection and repairs. Enclosing the news report helps.

Other roads to justice

Courts are not the only door. Article 39A directs the State to provide free legal aid, and the Legal Services Authorities Act 1987 created legal services authorities that give free legal help to eligible groups, among them women, children, members of Scheduled Castes and Tribes, persons in custody, persons with disabilities, industrial workers and people below an income limit. Lok Adalats help settle disputes by agreement. Commissions such as the NHRC, covered next, offer simpler remedies.

Key points

  • Article 32 (Supreme Court) and Article 226 (High Courts) let people enforce rights by writs; Article 226 is wider.
  • The five writs are habeas corpus, mandamus, prohibition, certiorari and quo warranto, each for a different kind of wrong.
  • PIL relaxed locus standi so that anyone acting in good faith can seek justice for those who cannot approach the court.
  • PIL has produced landmark rights judgments, but critics warn of misuse and judicial overreach.
  • Free legal aid and Lok Adalats help ordinary people reach justice.

Institutions, Groups and Debates

Lesson 7The Protection of Human Rights Act 1993 and the NHRC

Not everyone can reach the Supreme Court. Is there a simpler place to complain when a public servant violates your rights? Yes: the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC).

Why the Act was passed

In the early 1990s India faced serious concern about custodial violence, and the UN was urging states to set up national human rights institutions that follow the Paris Principles: independence, a broad mandate and proper powers. The Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993 (first issued as an ordinance in September 1993 and enacted in January 1994) set up the NHRC, which began work on 12 October 1993. Its first chairperson was Justice Ranganath Misra, a former Chief Justice of India.

The Act defines human rights as “the rights relating to life, liberty, equality and dignity of the individual guaranteed by the Constitution or embodied in the International Covenants and enforceable by courts in India”. The “International Covenants” are the ICCPR and the ICESCR of Lesson 3. This is the point where an international treaty enters Indian law directly.

Who sits on the NHRC

  • Chairperson: a person who has been Chief Justice of India or a Judge of the Supreme Court.
  • Members: one who is or has been a Judge of the Supreme Court; one who is or has been a High Court Chief Justice; and three persons with knowledge or experience of human rights, at least one of them a woman.
  • Deemed members: the chairpersons of several other national commissions, such as those for Women, Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and Minorities.
  • Appointment: by the President, on the recommendation of a committee of the Prime Minister (chair), the Speaker of the Lok Sabha, the Union Home Minister, the Leaders of the Opposition in both Houses and the Deputy Chairman of the Rajya Sabha.
  • Term: three years or until age 70, whichever is earlier. For misbehaviour or incapacity, the President can remove them only after an inquiry by the Supreme Court has proved the charge. This protects their independence.

What the NHRC does

Its functions include to:

  • inquire into complaints of human rights violations, or of negligence in preventing them, by a public servant, either on a complaint or on its own (suo motu);
  • intervene in court cases that involve human rights, with the court’s permission;
  • visit jails and other places of detention to study conditions;
  • review constitutional and legal safeguards and recommend changes;
  • spread human rights literacy and encourage the work of NGOs.

For inquiries it has the powers of a civil court: it can summon witnesses, demand documents and take evidence on affidavit. It has its own investigation staff, headed by a senior police officer. After an inquiry it may recommend that the government pay compensation, start prosecution or disciplinary action, or approach a court. The government must report back on the action taken within one month.

Filing a complaint

Meena’s brother dies in police custody and the family suspects torture. They can write to the NHRC on plain paper, or use the online complaint facility on its website, in Hindi or English. There is no fee and no lawyer is needed. A good complaint gives names and addresses, the date and place, a clear account of facts, the authority or officer concerned, and copies of papers such as the FIR and medical reports. The NHRC can call for a report from the authority, order its own inquiry and then make recommendations. Under its guidelines, authorities must report every death in custody to the NHRC within 24 hours.

Limits of the Commission

  • Its recommendations are not binding. It cannot punish or order payment; it must persuade.
  • It normally cannot inquire into an event more than one year old.
  • For complaints against members of the armed forces, it can only seek a report from the Central Government and make recommendations.

State Commissions and Human Rights Courts

States may set up State Human Rights Commissions (SHRCs), which deal with violations on subjects in the State List and Concurrent List. The Act also provides for Human Rights Courts: in each district, a Sessions Court may be specified to try offences arising from human rights violations quickly, with a Special Public Prosecutor.

How well does it work?

Supporters say the NHRC gives ordinary people a free and simple route, is headed by senior judges, can act on news reports, and puts public pressure on authorities even when it cannot compel them. Critics say its recommendations lack force, its power over the armed forces is limited, its inquiries often depend on officers drawn from the police and government, and, in their view, the appointment committee favours the government of the day. Reform proposals usually try to answer these points.

Key points

  • The Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993 created the NHRC, which began work on 12 October 1993.
  • The Act defines human rights by the Constitution and the two International Covenants, as enforceable by courts in India.
  • The NHRC is led by a former Chief Justice of India or Judge of the Supreme Court; misbehaviour or incapacity must be proved by a Supreme Court inquiry before removal.
  • It inquires into violations by public servants and recommends compensation or action, but its recommendations are not binding.
  • States have SHRCs, and districts may have Human Rights Courts.

Lesson 8Rights of Women and Children

The Constitution promises equality to everyone. Why, then, do women and children need special laws? Because equality on paper can still leave people unequal in life, and because children often cannot speak up for themselves.

Women: equality in the Constitution

The Constitution protects women through several articles.

  • Article 15(1) bans discrimination on grounds of sex, and Article 15(3) allows the State to make special provisions for women and children. This exception supports protective laws.
  • Article 39(d) directs equal pay for equal work for men and women, and Article 42 asks for humane conditions of work and maternity relief.
  • Article 51A(e) makes it a duty of every citizen to renounce practices that insult the dignity of women.
  • The 73rd and 74th Amendments (1992) reserved at least one-third of the seats in panchayats and municipalities for women.
  • The Constitution (106th Amendment) Act, 2023 (the Nari Shakti Vandan Adhiniyam) provides one-third reservation for women in the Lok Sabha and State Legislative Assemblies, to take effect after the next delimitation of constituencies.

Key laws for women

LawWhat it does
Dowry Prohibition Act, 1961Makes giving, taking or demanding dowry an offence
Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005Gives civil remedies, such as protection orders, the right to stay in the shared household and monetary relief, to a woman facing violence in a domestic relationship
Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal) Act, 2013Requires an Internal Committee in every workplace with 10 or more employees to receive and inquire into complaints
Maternity Benefit Act, 1961 (amended 2017)Gives 26 weeks of paid maternity leave for the first two children
Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005Gives daughters the same rights as sons in joint family property
National Commission for Women Act, 1990Created the National Commission for Women (set up in 1992) to review safeguards, look into complaints and advise the government

From Bhanwari Devi to the 2013 Act

In 1992 Bhanwari Devi, a grassroots worker in a Rajasthan government programme for women, was gang-raped after she tried to stop a child marriage in her village. Women’s groups filed a petition, and in Vishaka v State of Rajasthan (1997) the Supreme Court laid down guidelines against sexual harassment at work. Parliament turned them into the 2013 Act. Separately, after the Delhi gang rape of December 2012, a committee headed by Justice J. S. Verma recommended changes in criminal law, and Parliament amended the law in 2013.

Children

A child is a person below 18 under the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC) and in most Indian laws. The CRC (adopted in 1989; India joined in 1992) rests on four guiding principles:

  1. Non-discrimination: every child has all the rights, without exception.
  2. Best interests of the child: this must come first in decisions that affect children.
  3. Life, survival and development: the State must protect and support the child’s growth.
  4. Respect for the views of the child: children have a right to be heard on matters affecting them.

The Constitution speaks directly for children. Article 21A gives free and compulsory education from 6 to 14, Article 24 bans work by children below 14 in factories, mines and other hazardous jobs, and Article 39(e) and (f) direct the State to protect children from abuse and from being forced by need into unsuitable work and to give them chances to grow in freedom and dignity.

LawWhat it does
Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act, 2009Education for ages 6 to 14; private unaided schools must keep 25 per cent of entry-level seats for children from disadvantaged groups and weaker sections
Child Labour (Prohibition and Regulation) Act, 1986, as amended in 2016Bans work by children under 14 in all occupations, except helping in a family business after school hours or working as a child artist under conditions; bans adolescents (14 to 18) from hazardous work
Prohibition of Child Marriage Act, 2006Sets the minimum age at 18 for girls and 21 for boys and makes child marriage an offence
Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act, 2012Protects children under 18 from sexual abuse, with child-friendly procedures and special courts
Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015Provides care for children in need and a separate system for children in conflict with the law

The National Commission for the Protection of Child Rights (NCPCR) was set up in 2007 to monitor these laws, and a national helpline, Childline (1098), helps children in distress.

Which law applies?

  • A 12-year-old washes dishes at a roadside eatery for wages. The child labour law bans this, and Article 24 backs it.
  • A family plans to marry off a 16-year-old girl. This is a child marriage, an offence under the 2006 Act; the police or Childline can be called.
  • A man sexually abuses a 10-year-old neighbour. This is covered by the POCSO Act, which also makes it an offence to hide knowledge of such abuse.
  • A government school refuses an eligible 7-year-old a seat because the family has no birth certificate. The Right to Education Act says no child may be denied admission for lack of age proof.

Law and life

Laws alone do not change life. Under-reporting, delays, and social attitudes often matter as much as the text of the law. Debates continue: some argue that laws on matters such as dowry harassment are sometimes misused, while others say that under-reporting and delayed justice are the larger problem. Courts have asked the police to follow proper procedure before arrest while accepting that these laws serve a real need.

Key points

  • Article 15(3) allows special provisions for women and children; other articles cover equal pay, maternity relief and dignity.
  • Key laws for women include the Dowry Prohibition Act, the Domestic Violence Act 2005 and the 2013 Act on sexual harassment at work; Vishaka (1997) filled the gap before it.
  • The CRC’s four principles are non-discrimination, best interests, life and development, and the child’s views.
  • Children are protected by the RTE Act, child labour, child marriage and POCSO laws, and the NCPCR.
  • Laws need awareness, reporting and fair enforcement to change lives.

Lesson 9Rights of Scheduled Castes and Tribes, Persons with Disabilities and Workers

Equality on paper is not always equality in life. How does the Constitution treat groups that have faced exclusion, barriers or hardship?

Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes

Scheduled Castes (SCs) and Scheduled Tribes (STs) are communities listed in official Schedules under Articles 341 and 342. Many SC communities were once treated as “untouchable” and shut out of wells, temples and schools. Many ST communities live in forest and hill regions and have faced loss of land and forest.

The Constitution responds in several ways.

  • Article 17 abolishes untouchability, and Article 15(2) guarantees equal access to shops, restaurants, wells and other public places.
  • Articles 15(4) and 16(4) allow special provisions and reservations in education and public jobs, and Article 46 directs the State to promote their educational and economic interests.
  • Articles 330 and 332 reserve seats in the Lok Sabha and State Assemblies, and Articles 338 and 338A create National Commissions for SCs and STs.
  • The Fifth and Sixth Schedules provide a special system for administering Scheduled Areas and tribal areas.

Laws add protection. The Protection of Civil Rights Act, 1955 punishes untouchability. The SC and ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 lists offences against SC and ST members, such as forcing someone to eat or drink obnoxious substances, social boycott and blocking access to common resources like water, and provides special courts. The Prohibition of Employment as Manual Scavengers and their Rehabilitation Act, 2013 bans manual scavenging. The Forest Rights Act, 2006 recognises the rights of forest-dwelling communities over forest land and resources, and PESA (1996) gives gram sabhas special powers in Scheduled Areas.

Persons with disabilities

Older laws saw disability as a matter of charity and medical care. The UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (CRPD) of 2006, which India joined in 2007, changed the view: persons with disabilities are rights-holders, and much disability arises from barriers such as stairs without ramps or websites that screen readers cannot read.

The Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016 replaced the 1995 Act. It:

  • recognises 21 types of disability;
  • bans discrimination and requires reasonable accommodation;
  • requires accessible buildings, transport and information;
  • reserves 4 per cent of government posts, and 5 per cent of seats in higher education, for persons with “benchmark disabilities” (at least 40 per cent of a specified disability);
  • ensures free education up to age 18 for children with benchmark disabilities;
  • provides a Chief Commissioner and State Commissioners to hear complaints.

The Mental Healthcare Act, 2017 gives every person a right to access mental healthcare.

Reasonable accommodation

Aman has low vision and is sitting an entrance exam. A large-print paper, extra time, a screen reader or a scribe are adjustments that let him show his ability on equal terms. The Act defines reasonable accommodation as necessary and appropriate changes that do not impose a disproportionate or undue burden. It is not a favour; it makes equality real.

Workers

The Constitution protects workers in many ways: Article 19(1)(c) (forming unions), Article 23 (no forced labour), Article 24 (no child labour in hazardous work), and the Directive Principles on a living wage, humane conditions and workers’ participation in management (Articles 39, 41, 42, 43 and 43A).

The International Labour Organization (ILO), founded in 1919, sets labour standards on freedom of association, ending forced labour and child labour, non-discrimination at work, and safe and healthy working conditions.

Indian laws include the Bonded Labour System (Abolition) Act, 1976, the Trade Unions Act, 1926, and the Unorganised Workers’ Social Security Act, 2008. In 2019 and 2020, Parliament passed four Labour Codes to combine 29 central laws on wages, industrial relations, social security and workplace safety. The Code on Social Security, 2020 recognises gig and platform workers for the first time. Most Indian workers are in the informal sector, with no written contract or social security, and the protection of these workers is a continuing challenge.

On strikes, the Supreme Court held in T. K. Rangarajan v Government of Tamil Nadu (2003) that government employees have no fundamental right to strike.

The Asiad workers case

Before the 1982 Asian Games in Delhi, contractors paid construction workers less than the minimum wage. In People’s Union for Democratic Rights v Union of India (1982), the Supreme Court held that work for less than the minimum wage can amount to forced labour under Article 23, because a poor worker has no real choice but to accept. It also held that Article 23 can be claimed against private contractors, not only against the State.

Key points

  • SCs and STs are protected by Articles 15(2), 17, 46 and 338/338A, reserved seats, the 1989 Atrocities Act, the Forest Rights Act and PESA.
  • Persons with disabilities are now seen as rights-holders; the RPwD Act 2016 requires non-discrimination, accessibility and reasonable accommodation.
  • The Act reserves 4 per cent of government posts and 5 per cent of higher-education seats for benchmark disabilities.
  • Workers are protected by Articles 19(1)(c), 23 and 24 and the Directive Principles; the Asiad case linked minimum wage to forced labour.
  • The Labour Codes of 2019 and 2020 recognise gig workers, but informal workers still need stronger protection.

Lesson 10Current Debates and Putting It All Together

Almost everyone accepts human rights in principle. So why do thoughtful people disagree so sharply about them in practice? Because rights sometimes collide with each other or with public interests, and reasonable people weigh them differently.

Why rights collide

Free speech can clash with a person’s dignity. Liberty can clash with security. Religious freedom can clash with equality. Law uses two tools: reasonable restrictions written into the Constitution, and proportionality. In the privacy case (Puttaswamy, 2017), the Supreme Court said an action that limits a right must pass three tests: legality (it rests on a valid law), legitimate aim (it serves a real public purpose) and proportionality (the means suit the aim and go no further than needed).

Testing a restriction

After violent clashes, a district orders all internet services shut for three days. Legality: is there a law that allows the order? Aim: preventing violence is a legitimate aim. Proportionality: could a narrower step work, and is the order limited in area and time and open to review? In Anuradha Bhasin v Union of India (2020), the Supreme Court held that freedom of speech and the freedom to carry on trade through the internet are constitutionally protected, and that shutdown orders must be proportionate, limited in time and open to judicial review.

Four debates, two sides each

Each debate below gives the main arguments on both sides. Your task is to weigh them, not to take ours.

1. The death penalty

  • One view: For the gravest crimes, it delivers justice to victims and deters others. In Bachan Singh v State of Punjab (1980), the Supreme Court upheld it but limited it to the “rarest of rare” cases.
  • Another view: The right to life is the most basic right; a death sentence cannot be undone if a court errs; evidence that it deters better than life imprisonment is weak. The Law Commission’s 262nd Report (2015) recommended abolishing it for all crimes except terrorism-related offences.

2. Free speech, security and hate speech

  • One view: Democracy needs open criticism, and vague laws make people afraid to speak. In Shreya Singhal (2015), a vague provision was struck down. In 2022 the Supreme Court put the sedition law (Section 124A of the IPC) on hold.
  • Another view: Speech that incites violence or targets groups damages dignity and public order, and the State must act against real threats. The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (in force from 1 July 2024) has no section called sedition but Section 152 punishes acts endangering the sovereignty, unity and integrity of India. Supporters say it targets real threats; critics say it is as broad as the old law.

3. Privacy, technology and welfare

  • One view: Digital identity and data systems, such as Aadhaar, reduce leakage in welfare schemes and help fight crime. In 2018 the Supreme Court upheld Aadhaar for welfare benefits, with limits on its use.
  • Another view: Large databases allow profiling and surveillance, and a failed authentication can shut a poor person out of benefits. The Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 gives individuals rights over their data. The government says exemptions for State agencies are needed for security and public order; critics say they are too broad.

4. A Uniform Civil Code (Article 44)

  • One view: One family law for all would advance equality and gender justice. In Shayara Bano (2017), the Supreme Court held instant triple talaq unconstitutional.
  • Another view: Articles 25 to 29 protect religious freedom and culture, India is diverse, and reform should come through consultation and from within communities, not by imposing one code. In 2018 the Law Commission said a uniform code was neither necessary nor desirable “at this stage”, and in 2023 a new Law Commission invited public views. Goa has had a common family-law code since Portuguese times, and Uttarakhand passed a state law in 2024.

Putting it all together

Rights have three layers: international (UDHR, covenants and treaties), constitutional (Parts III and IV) and statutory (special laws and bodies). Courts and commissions connect them to real life.

If this happensA first step
Someone is held without being produced before a magistrateApproach the magistrate or lawyer; a habeas corpus petition in the High Court
A public servant violates your rightsComplain to the NHRC or the State Human Rights Commission
Sexual harassment at workThe Internal Committee of the workplace
A child is in dangerChildline (1098) or the police
You cannot afford a lawyerThe District Legal Services Authority

Keep learning

These topics appear in civil services, judiciary, UGC NET and law-entrance exams, and in careers in law, public service, journalism, social work, research and teaching. Read Parts III and IV of the Constitution itself, follow summaries of Supreme Court judgments, and read NHRC and UN reports. Mark three dates: 26 November (Constitution Day), 12 October (NHRC’s foundation) and 10 December (Human Rights Day).

Key points

  • Rights can conflict; courts test limits by legality, legitimate aim and proportionality.
  • On each current debate (death penalty, speech and security, privacy and technology, a Uniform Civil Code) serious arguments exist on both sides.
  • Rights work on three layers: international law, the Constitution and special statutes with their bodies.
  • Practical routes include the police and magistrates, High Courts, commissions, legal aid and helplines.
  • Learning to state both sides fairly is a core skill in human rights work.

Final quiz

Lesson 11Final quiz

This lesson is a quiz. Take it online: open the quiz.

10 questions on the whole course. Pass with 60% or more to complete the course and earn your certificate. You see the right answers with explanations after you submit, and you can retake it.

These notes are for your own study. Please do not share, upload or sell them.
© 2026 VJ Classes · vjclasses.in