The Constitution promises liberty and equality. Does it also promise food, work and a decent life, and if so, why can you not take the State to court when it fails to deliver? The answer lies in Part IV, the Directive Principles.
Directive Principles of State Policy
The Directive Principles of State Policy (DPSP) are in Part IV, Articles 36 to 51. They are directions to the Union and State governments about the kind of laws and policies they should make. The idea was borrowed from the Irish Constitution.
Article 37 says they are not enforceable by any court, yet they are “fundamental in the governance of the country” and it is the State’s duty to apply them in making laws. The framers knew that a poor, newly independent country could not guarantee everything at once, so they wrote a programme. Its aim was social and economic democracy. In his closing speech to the Constituent Assembly on 25 November 1949, Dr Ambedkar warned that India was entering “a life of contradictions”: equality in politics but inequality in social and economic life. The Directive Principles were meant to narrow that gap.
Scholars group the principles into three families. These labels are not in the text.
| Family | Examples |
|---|---|
| Socialist (welfare) | Art 38: promote welfare and reduce inequality; Art 39: adequate livelihood, equal pay for equal work for men and women; Art 41: work, education and public assistance; Art 42: humane conditions of work, maternity relief; Art 43: living wage |
| Gandhian | Art 40: village panchayats; Art 43: cottage industries; Art 46: education and economic interests of Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and weaker sections; Art 47: raising nutrition and public health, and prohibiting harmful drinks and drugs |
| Liberal-intellectual | Art 44: uniform civil code; Art 45: early childhood care and education; Art 48A: protecting the environment, forests and wildlife; Art 50: separating the judiciary from the executive; Art 51: international peace and respect for international law |
From principles to reality
Directive Principles become real in two ways. Parliament and State legislatures pass laws: the 73rd Amendment (1992) gave constitutional status to panchayats (Article 40); the Right to Education Act (2009) followed Article 21A; the Environment (Protection) Act (1986) draws on Article 48A. And courts read them into Article 21: in Olga Tellis v Bombay Municipal Corporation (1985), the Supreme Court held that the right to livelihood is part of the right to life, supported by Articles 39(a) and 41.
From principle to entitlement
Article 41 asks the State, within its means, to make provision for the right to work. In 2005 Parliament passed the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act, which created a legal right for rural households to ask for wage work. Article 47 makes raising nutrition and public health a primary duty, and the National Food Security Act (2013) gave a legal entitlement to subsidised foodgrains to a large share of the population. In both cases a principle that no court could enforce directly became a law that people could claim.
Fundamental Rights and Directive Principles: a changing balance
In State of Madras v Champakam Dorairajan (1951), the Court held that when the two conflict, Fundamental Rights prevail. Parliament later tried to give some Directive Principles priority, through the 25th and 42nd Amendments. In Minerva Mills v Union of India (1980) the Supreme Court held that the Constitution rests on a balance between Part III and Part IV, and that giving either absolute priority would destroy that balance. Today courts try to harmonise the two.
“Non-justiciable” does not mean “unimportant”
You cannot sue the State merely because it has not carried out a Directive Principle. But Article 37 makes them fundamental in governance, courts use them to interpret rights and to uphold laws that advance them, and Parliament turns them into entitlements.
Fundamental Duties
Part IVA, Article 51A, was added by the 42nd Amendment (1976), on the recommendation of the Swaran Singh Committee. It began with ten duties; an eleventh was added in 2002. Citizens are to:
- respect the Constitution, the National Flag and the National Anthem;
- cherish the ideals of the freedom struggle and defend the country;
- promote harmony and brotherhood across religious, linguistic and regional differences, and renounce practices that insult the dignity of women;
- value the nation’s heritage and protect the natural environment;
- develop scientific temper, humanism and the spirit of inquiry;
- safeguard public property, give up violence and strive for excellence.
The eleventh duty asks a parent or guardian to provide opportunities for education to a child aged 6 to 14. Fundamental Duties carry no penalty in the Constitution itself, but courts have used them, for example the environmental duty, when interpreting laws.
Views differ on their value. Supporters say duties remind citizens that rights live in a community, an idea close to Gandhi’s belief that rights grow out of duty well done, and echoed in Article 29 of the UDHR. Critics reply that a person’s rights should never depend on performing duties, and that vague duties could be used against dissent. Both arguments have been made in Parliament and in the courts.
Key points
- Directive Principles (Part IV, Articles 36 to 51) guide the State towards social and economic democracy; Article 37 makes them non-justiciable but fundamental in governance.
- They are often grouped as socialist, Gandhian and liberal-intellectual.
- They become real through laws such as the Right to Education Act, MGNREGA and the National Food Security Act, and through courts reading them into Article 21.
- Minerva Mills (1980) holds that the Constitution rests on a balance between Fundamental Rights and Directive Principles.
- Fundamental Duties (Article 51A, from 1976, eleven in number) are not directly enforceable; their value is debated.