How do we test a moral view? Not in a laboratory. Ethics uses two kinds of evidence: intuitions (our considered sense that something is right or wrong) and arguments (reasons that connect principles to cases).
Intuitions are data, not verdicts
Nearly everyone feels that torturing a child for fun is wrong, and that keeping a promise matters. Such intuitions are where ethical thinking starts. But intuitions can also reflect prejudice, self-interest or simple habit: for centuries many people “felt” that women should not vote. So intuitions are like observations in science: valuable, but open to correction.
Reflective equilibrium
The philosopher John Rawls described a method he called reflective equilibrium. You move back and forth between general principles (“we should not use people merely as tools”) and judgements about particular cases (“this employer is exploiting workers”). When they clash, you revise whichever seems less secure, until principles and judgements fit together. Most careful ethical thinking works this way, even when it is not called by that name.
Four tests for any moral argument
- Consistency. Do you judge similar cases alike? If cheating is wrong when others do it, it is wrong when you do it.
- Universalisability. Could you accept your principle if everyone followed it?
- Role reversal. Would you accept the decision if you were the person most affected by it?
- Publicity. Could you defend your reasoning openly, in front of the people affected?
Testing an excuse
“Everyone in my office takes small gifts from suppliers, so it’s fine.”
- Consistency: Would you accept it if the officer handling your application took gifts from the other side?
- Universalisability: If every official took gifts, decisions would go to whoever gave most.
- Publicity: Would you be comfortable if the gifts were listed on the company website? The excuse fails all three. “Everyone does it” describes behaviour; it does not justify it.
How reasoning goes wrong
- Self-serving bias: we find reasons for conclusions that suit us.
- In-group bias: we judge “our people” more kindly than others.
- Moral licensing: after doing one good deed, we feel entitled to a bad one.
- Euphemism: calling a bribe a “speed fee” makes it feel less wrong.
Psychologists have shown that people often reach a moral verdict quickly and then search for reasons afterwards. Good moral reasoning deliberately slows down and asks whether the reasons came first.
Common mistake
Treating a strong feeling as a complete argument. “I feel strongly that this is wrong” tells us about you; an argument tells us about the act.
Try this
Pick a moral belief you hold firmly. Write the principle behind it, then find a case where that principle gives an answer you dislike. Do you revise the principle or the judgement about the case? That is reflective equilibrium in action.
Key points
- Intuitions are evidence in ethics, but they can be corrected.
- Reflective equilibrium balances principles and case judgements.
- Consistency, universalisability, role reversal and publicity are practical tests.
- Watch for self-serving bias, in-group bias and euphemism.