Skip to content
VJ Classes

One place to learn science, commerce, arts, computers and life skills

Ethics asks how we ought to live and act: what is right, what is good, and what we owe to each other. It sounds simple until we notice how often it gets mixed up with other things.

Ethics is not just law

Many legal acts are unethical (breaking a promise to a friend is rarely illegal), and some illegal acts have been deeply ethical (the satyagrahis who broke the salt law in 1930). Law sets the minimum a society enforces; ethics asks what is actually right, and can be used to criticise the law itself.

Ethics is not just custom or religion

Customs vary between places and change over time. Practices once widely accepted, such as untouchability or child marriage, were defended by custom and later recognised as wrong. If ethics were only custom, the reformers who opposed them could never have been right; they could only have been different.

Religion is a major source of moral teaching for many people, and religious traditions contain profound ethical insight. But philosophers have long asked a question first raised in Plato’s dialogue Euthyphro: is something good because it is commanded, or is it commanded because it is good? If the second, then goodness has reasons we can examine and discuss with people of every faith and none.

Describing versus judging

  • Descriptive claims say how things are: “Most people in the survey think lying is acceptable in some cases.”
  • Normative claims say how things ought to be: “Lying is acceptable in some cases.”

The Scottish philosopher David Hume observed that you cannot move from an “is” to an “ought” without adding a value premise. Facts matter enormously in ethics, but facts alone never settle what we should do.

Is it all relative?

Moral relativism says right and wrong are simply what each culture (or each person) believes. It sounds tolerant, but it has awkward consequences: we could never say that a society which practised slavery was mistaken, and the idea of moral progress would make no sense. Most philosophers hold that while many practices rightly differ between cultures, some judgements, such as that cruelty for fun is wrong, are not merely local preferences.

Three kinds of “should”

  • “You should use a fork for noodles in this restaurant.” (etiquette)
  • “You should file your tax return by the due date.” (law)
  • “You should return the extra change the shopkeeper gave you by mistake.” (ethics)

Only the third holds even if nobody would ever find out.

Try this

List three things you think are wrong but legal, and three things that are illegal but which you think could sometimes be right. What does each list tell you about the relation between law and ethics?

Key points

  • Ethics concerns what is right and good, not merely what is legal or customary.
  • The Euthyphro question asks whether goodness depends on command or has its own reasons.
  • Normative claims cannot be derived from facts alone (Hume’s is-ought gap).
  • Strong relativism makes moral criticism and moral progress impossible to explain.