In everyday language an argument is a fight. In logic, an argument is a set of reasons offered in support of a claim. The claim being defended is the conclusion; the reasons are the premises.
Take: "Ravi always tops the class, so he will clear the entrance exam." The conclusion is that Ravi will clear the exam. The premise is that he always tops the class. Notice that the premise could be true while the conclusion is still false — class tests and entrance exams are different things.
The first habit of a critical thinker is simple: before agreeing or disagreeing, find the conclusion, then list the reasons given for it. Half of all confusion in discussions comes from people arguing about different conclusions without noticing.