← Critical Thinking: The Basics

To keep these notes as a PDF, press "Download PDF" and choose "Save as PDF" as the printer. On a phone: open the browser menu, tap Share or Print, then Save as PDF.

VJ Classes

Course notes

Critical Thinking: The Basics

Spot weak arguments, avoid common traps and decide more clearly.

What you will learn

Contents

How arguments work

Lesson 1What is an argument?

In everyday language an argument is a fight. In logic, an argument is a set of reasons offered in support of a claim. The claim being defended is the conclusion; the reasons are the premises.

Take: "Ravi always tops the class, so he will clear the entrance exam." The conclusion is that Ravi will clear the exam. The premise is that he always tops the class. Notice that the premise could be true while the conclusion is still false — class tests and entrance exams are different things.

The first habit of a critical thinker is simple: before agreeing or disagreeing, find the conclusion, then list the reasons given for it. Half of all confusion in discussions comes from people arguing about different conclusions without noticing.

Lesson 2Deduction and induction

A deductive argument claims that its conclusion follows with certainty: "All mammals breathe air. A whale is a mammal. So a whale breathes air." If the premises are true and the form is valid, the conclusion cannot be false.

An inductive argument claims only that its conclusion is probable: "The last 40 monsoons reached Kerala in early June, so this one probably will too." Good inductive arguments can still have false conclusions — that is not a flaw, it is their nature.

Knowing which kind of argument you are facing tells you how to test it. For deduction, check the structure. For induction, check the size and fairness of the evidence.

Lesson 3Is it valid? Is it sound?

An argument is valid when the conclusion would have to be true if the premises were true. It is sound when it is valid and its premises actually are true.

"All birds can fly. A penguin is a bird. So a penguin can fly." This is valid — the structure works — but it is not sound, because the first premise is false.

So there are always two separate questions: does the conclusion follow, and are the starting points true? Exams love testing the first; real life usually fails on the second.

Traps to avoid

Lesson 4Five fallacies you will meet every week

A fallacy is a mistake in reasoning that can still sound persuasive. Five common ones:

  • Ad hominem — attacking the person instead of the argument ("He failed once, so his idea is wrong").
  • Straw man — replacing someone's view with a weaker version and defeating that.
  • False dilemma — offering two options when more exist ("Either you join coaching or you will fail").
  • Appeal to popularity — "Everyone believes it, so it must be true."
  • Hasty generalisation — a big conclusion from a few cases.

Naming a fallacy is not the same as winning an argument. Use the names to slow yourself down, not to score points.

Lesson 5Questions that protect you

When a claim matters — before you believe it, share it or act on it — ask:

  • What exactly is being claimed?
  • What reasons or evidence are given?
  • Would those reasons convince me if I disliked the conclusion?
  • What would have to be true for this to be false?
  • Who gains if I believe it?

These questions take a minute. They will save you from most rumours, many bad purchases and a few bad decisions. The short quiz that follows checks the ideas from this course.

Lesson 6Final quiz

This lesson is a quiz. Take it online: open the quiz.

Eight questions on this course. Score 60% or more to complete it. You can retake the quiz.

These notes are for your own study. Please do not share, upload or sell them.
© 2026 VJ Classes · vjclasses.in