Skip to content
VJ Classes

One place to learn science, commerce, arts, computers and life skills

Aman promises his friend Rahul ₹10,000 as a birthday gift. A bank promises Aman a ₹10,000 loan. If both promises are broken, only one can be enforced in court. Which one, and why?

The answer lies in three tests a contract must pass after offer and acceptance: there must be consideration, the parties must have capacity, and their consent must be free.

Consideration: the price of a promise

Consideration is what each side gives, or promises to give, in exchange for the other’s promise. Section 2(d) of the Contract Act says it is something done, not done, or promised at the desire of the promisor, by the promisee or by any other person. In the loan, the bank’s consideration is the ₹10,000 and Aman’s is his promise to repay. In the gift, Rahul gives nothing, so a bare promise of a gift cannot be enforced.

The main rules are:

  • It must be given at the desire of the promisor.
  • It may come from the promisee or from any other person, but only a party to the contract can sue on it.
  • It may be past, present or future. Under the Indian definition, something done earlier at the promisor’s desire can support a later promise.
  • It must be real and lawful, but it need not be adequate. A court does not ask whether the price was fair. If Priya sells her old phone for ₹3,000 though it is worth ₹5,000, the contract stands, unless her consent was not free.

Section 25 lists exceptions in which a promise binds without consideration: a promise out of natural love and affection between near relatives, if it is in writing and registered; a promise to compensate for past voluntary services; and a written, signed promise to pay a debt that has become time-barred. A gift that has actually been handed over is also valid, because it is already complete.

Spot the consideration

Ritu in Ludhiana agrees to sell her scooter to Manoj for ₹40,000. Her consideration is the scooter; his is the ₹40,000. Both are real, so the contract is valid even if the scooter’s market value is ₹50,000.

Later Ritu promises her nephew a laptop for his birthday and asks for nothing in return. Unless she actually hands it over, he cannot enforce the promise: there is no consideration and no exception applies.

Capacity: who can contract

Section 11 says a person is competent to contract if he or she has reached the age of majority, is of sound mind, and is not disqualified by any law.

  • Age of majority. Under the Indian Majority Act, 1875, a person becomes a major at 18, or at 21 if a court has appointed a guardian for the person or property.
  • Minors. The Privy Council held in Mohori Bibee v Dharmodas Ghose (1903) that a minor’s agreement is void from the very beginning. A minor cannot be sued on it, cannot ratify it on turning 18, and cannot be made to pay under it. A minor can, however, be a beneficiary, for example a promisee. A person who supplies necessaries suited to the minor’s life, such as food, clothing or schooling, can be paid out of the minor’s property, but the minor is not personally liable.
  • Unsound mind. The person must be able to understand the contract and judge its effect on his or her interests when making it. Someone usually of unsound mind may contract in a lucid interval; someone usually sound may not contract while delirious or severely intoxicated.
  • Others. The law limits the power to contract of persons such as alien enemies during war, insolvents, and companies, which may act only within the objects stated in their constitution.

A teenager’s purchase

A 16-year-old in Chandigarh promises to buy a drone for ₹30,000 from a shop and pays nothing. The shop cannot sue him for the price, because his agreement is void. The safer course for any seller is to deal with an adult.

Free consent

Parties consent when they agree upon the same thing in the same sense. Consent is free when it is not caused by coercion, undue influence, fraud, misrepresentation or mistake (section 14).

FactorWhat it meansEffect
CoercionCommitting or threatening an act forbidden by criminal law, or unlawfully holding property, to force an agreementVoidable at the victim’s option
Undue influenceOne side dominates the other’s will through a relationship of trust or authority and takes unfair advantageVoidable
FraudDeliberate deception to get the other side to contract, such as a lie told knowingly or active hiding of a factVoidable, and damages may be claimed
MisrepresentationA false statement made innocently, without intent to deceiveVoidable
Mistake of both partiesBoth are wrong about a fact essential to the agreementVoid

A voidable contract stands until the injured party chooses to cancel it. The criminal law referred to in the definition of coercion was the Indian Penal Code, now replaced by the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023; the idea is unchanged. Mere silence is not fraud unless there is a duty to speak, as in insurance, where the buyer must disclose important facts. A party who could have found the truth with ordinary care cannot avoid the contract for misrepresentation. A mistake by one party only, or a mistake about Indian law, does not make a contract voidable.

Which factor is it?

(a) A moneylender threatens to beat a shopkeeper unless he signs a loan paper. (b) A seller honestly but wrongly says a machine is only two years old. (c) A dealer knowingly hides that a truck’s engine has been replaced with a damaged one.

Answers: (a) coercion, voidable; (b) misrepresentation, voidable; (c) fraud, voidable, and the buyer may also claim damages.

Key points

  • Consideration is something given in return for a promise, at the promisor’s desire; it must be real and lawful but need not be adequate.
  • A bare promise without consideration is not enforceable, except in the cases listed in section 25.
  • A minor’s agreement is void from the start; a major of sound mind and not disqualified by law is competent to contract.
  • Consent is free only if not caused by coercion, undue influence, fraud, misrepresentation or mistake.
  • Contracts made without free consent are voidable at the injured party’s option, while a mistake shared by both sides about an essential fact makes the agreement void.