Meera runs a small bakery in Pune. A college fest committee sends her a message: “We need 200 cupcakes on Friday at ₹30 each.” Meera replies, “Done.” On Wednesday the fest is cancelled and the committee says it no longer wants the cupcakes. Meera has already bought the ingredients. Can she demand the money?
This is the question business law exists to answer: when does a promise stop being a mere promise and become something the law will enforce? The answer decides who can sue, who must pay and who can walk away.
Agreement and contract
The law of contract in India is mainly found in the Indian Contract Act, 1872. It gives two key definitions.
- An agreement is a promise, or a set of promises, made in exchange for each other.
- A contract is an agreement that the law will enforce.
So every contract is an agreement, but not every agreement is a contract. If two friends agree to watch a film on Sunday, neither can sue the other for backing out, because they did not intend a legal relationship. In business dealings the law presumes that people do intend one.
Section 10 lists what turns an agreement into a contract. It must be made by the free consent of parties who are competent to contract, for a lawful consideration and a lawful object, and it must not be one that the Act expressly declares void. Offer and acceptance come first, and the next lessons cover the rest.
The offer
An offer (the Act calls it a proposal) is made when one person shows willingness to do something, or to refrain from doing something, in order to get the other person’s agreement. The person who makes it is the offeror; the person who receives it is the offeree.
A valid offer is:
- clear and definite: “I may sell my shop someday” is not an offer;
- meant to create a legal relationship;
- communicated to the offeree, in words or by conduct (a passenger who boards a city bus offers, by conduct, to pay the fare).
An offer can be specific (made to one person) or general (made to the public). In the English case Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Co (1893), a company advertised a reward of £100 to anyone who used its product as directed and still caught influenza. Mrs Carlill did so and claimed the reward. The court held that the advertisement was an offer to the whole world, accepted by doing what it asked. Indian courts follow the same principle.
Not every statement of price is an offer. A price tag on a shirt, a restaurant menu, a catalogue, an online listing and a notice calling for tenders are usually invitations to treat: they invite others to make offers. The customer who takes the shirt to the counter makes the offer, and the shopkeeper accepts by billing it. This protects a shopkeeper who has marked a wrong price by mistake.
Meera’s cupcakes
The committee’s message states the item (cupcakes), the quantity (200), the price (₹30 each) and the date (Friday). It is clear, definite and communicated, so it is an offer. Meera’s reply “Done” is an unqualified agreement, so it is an acceptance, and a contract is formed for 200 × ₹30 = ₹6,000.
Had she replied “Yes, but ₹35 each”, she would have changed a term. That is a counter-offer: it rejects the original offer and makes a new one worth 200 × ₹35 = ₹7,000, which the committee may accept or refuse.
Acceptance
Acceptance is the offeree’s agreement to the terms of the offer. Once an offer is accepted it becomes a promise. The rules are:
- It must be absolute and unqualified. Any change in the terms is a counter-offer.
- It must be given by the person to whom the offer was made.
- It must be communicated to the offeror, in the manner the offeror prescribed or, if none, in a usual and reasonable manner. Silence is not acceptance.
- It must come while the offer is still open.
- The acceptor must know of the offer. In the Allahabad case Lalman Shukla v Gauri Dutt (1913), a servant who traced his master’s missing nephew without knowing about the announced reward was held not entitled to it.
An offer can be revoked (withdrawn) by notice at any time before it is accepted. It also ends if the offeree rejects it or makes a counter-offer, or if the time limit, or a reasonable time, runs out. Once acceptance is complete, the offeror can no longer withdraw. For a letter, acceptance is complete against the offeror as soon as it is posted. For instant modes such as a phone call, e-mail or WhatsApp message, courts look to when the acceptance reaches the offeror.
Offer, counter-offer or acceptance?
A sweet shop owner in Kota writes to a wholesaler: “Please send 50 kg of besan at ₹90 per kg.” The wholesaler replies: “I can send 40 kg at ₹90 per kg.” Is there a contract?
Answer: not yet. The change of quantity makes the reply a counter-offer, which ends the original offer. A contract arises only if the shop owner now accepts the offer of 40 kg, for 40 × ₹90 = ₹3,600.
Silence is not acceptance
A trader e-mails a buyer: “If I do not hear from you by Monday, I will assume you have agreed to the price.” The buyer does not reply. There is no contract. An offeror cannot force the offeree to speak.
Key points
- A contract is an agreement that the law enforces; section 10 of the Contract Act lists the essentials.
- An offer must be clear, definite, communicated and meant to create legal relations; a price tag or menu is usually only an invitation to treat.
- Acceptance must be absolute, unqualified, communicated and given while the offer is open; silence is not acceptance.
- A change of terms is a counter-offer and ends the original offer.
- A general offer to the public can be accepted by performing its conditions, but only by someone who knows of it.