Not every audit is the same. A shareholder, a bank and the Government each need a different kind of assurance, and the law asks for some audits and leaves others to choice. This lesson sorts the main types of audit and then introduces the rulebook that guides the auditor’s work.
Types of audit
Audits can be grouped in several ways. The most useful grouping for a beginner is by purpose.
| Type | Who requires it | What it does |
|---|---|---|
| Statutory audit | The law, for example the Companies Act, 2013 | An independent auditor reports to the owners on the annual financial statements |
| Voluntary audit | The owners, partners or a lender | A business that is not legally bound chooses an audit, often to satisfy a bank |
| Internal audit | The management or board | A function inside the entity (or an outsourced firm) checks controls, risks and efficiency throughout the year |
| Government audit | The Constitution and statutes | The Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) audits government accounts |
Statutory audit is the one this course concentrates on. The auditor is independent of the management and reports to the owners (shareholders). Internal audit is different: it is carried out for the management, covers operations as well as accounts, and its findings are used to improve the business. Certain classes of companies must appoint an internal auditor under the Companies Act.
Audits by timing and by special purpose
An audit can also be described by when the work is done.
- Final audit (balance sheet audit) starts after the year ends, when the books are closed.
- Interim audit is carried out at a point during the year, for example half-yearly, before the final audit.
- Continuous audit means the audit staff visit the client at regular intervals throughout the year. It suits large businesses with many transactions.
- Concurrent audit checks transactions close to the time they happen. Banks use it widely to catch errors early.
Some audits serve a special purpose set by law.
- Tax audit. A chartered accountant examines the books of certain taxpayers and reports specified particulars under the income tax law. The turnover limits and the rules change from time to time, so always check the current law.
- Cost audit. A cost accountant in practice audits the cost records of specified classes of companies under the Companies Act.
- Secretarial audit. A practising company secretary checks compliance with company law and other applicable laws for specified companies.
- Government audit. The Comptroller and Auditor General of India is a constitutional authority under Article 148. The CAG audits the accounts of the Union and the States, and takes part in the audit of government companies.
Reading the label
A small trading firm in Jind asks its CA for “a tax audit” and “a bank audit” in the same year. These are two different reports for two different readers. The first is a report required by tax law; the second is a voluntary audit requested by a lender. The same books support both, but the questions the auditor answers are not the same.
Standards on Auditing (SAs)
How do thousands of auditors in India follow a common method? Through the Standards on Auditing (SAs). These are issued by the ICAI, through its Auditing and Assurance Standards Board, and are based on the International Standards on Auditing (ISAs). The Companies Act, 2013 requires company auditors to follow them, and an audit report states that the audit was conducted in accordance with the SAs.
Each SA has a similar structure: an objective, definitions, requirements (the things the auditor must do) and application material that explains how. The SAs are numbered in series, so the number tells you the topic.
| Series | Area |
|---|---|
| 200–299 | General principles and responsibilities |
| 300–499 | Risk assessment and response to assessed risks |
| 500–599 | Audit evidence |
| 600–699 | Using the work of others |
| 700–799 | Audit conclusions and reporting |
| 800–899 | Special areas |
A few SAs you will meet repeatedly:
| SA | Topic |
|---|---|
| SA 200 | Overall objectives of the independent auditor |
| SA 240 | The auditor’s responsibilities relating to fraud |
| SA 300 | Planning an audit |
| SA 315 | Identifying and assessing the risks of material misstatement |
| SA 320 | Materiality in planning and performing an audit |
| SA 500 | Audit evidence |
| SA 530 | Audit sampling |
| SA 700 | Forming an opinion and reporting on financial statements |
| SA 705 | Modifications to the opinion in the auditor’s report |
Reading an SA number
An audit file notes: “Inventory count observed, see SA 501.” Because 501 lies in the 500–599 series, you know at once that the topic is audit evidence. A note that says “see SA 330” points to the 300–499 series, so it concerns how the auditor responds to assessed risks.
The objective of an audit: SA 200
SA 200 states two overall objectives. First, to obtain reasonable assurance about whether the financial statements as a whole are free from material misstatement, whether due to fraud or error, so that the auditor can express an opinion on whether they are prepared, in all material respects, in accordance with the applicable financial reporting framework. Second, to report on the statements and communicate as the SAs require, in line with the auditor’s findings.
SA 200 also asks the auditor to work with professional scepticism, which means a questioning mind, alertness to conditions that may indicate a misstatement, and a critical assessment of audit evidence. It also requires professional judgement, because no rulebook can decide every case.
Scepticism is not suspicion
Professional scepticism does not mean assuming that the management is dishonest. It means asking “what is the evidence?” for every important claim and not accepting an explanation merely because it sounds reasonable.
Key points
- Statutory audit is required by law; voluntary audit is chosen; internal audit serves the management; government audit is done by the CAG.
- Audits are also described by timing (final, interim, continuous, concurrent) and by special purpose (tax, cost, secretarial).
- Standards on Auditing (SAs) are issued by the ICAI, based on ISAs, and grouped in numbered series by topic.
- SA 200 sets the overall objectives: reasonable assurance about material misstatement, and a report on the findings.
- Professional scepticism and professional judgement run through every audit.