Skip to content
VJ Classes

One place to learn science, commerce, arts, computers and life skills

Suppose you buy shares worth ₹5 lakh in a company, or a bank lends a business ₹50 lakh. The company’s accounts say it earned a profit of ₹2 crore this year. But the accounts were prepared by the very people who run the company. Why should you believe them?

That question is the reason auditing exists. Auditing is the process by which an independent, qualified person examines the financial statements of an entity and tells the users, in a written opinion, whether they can rely on them.

Who needs trustworthy accounts

The financial statements of a business are its balance sheet, statement of profit and loss, cash flow statement and notes. They are read by many people who cannot walk into the office and check the books themselves:

  • Owners and shareholders, who want to know how their money is being used.
  • Lenders, such as banks, who decide whether to lend and on what terms.
  • Tax authorities, who compute tax on the reported profit.
  • Employees, suppliers and customers, who want to know whether the business is stable.
  • Regulators, who must protect the public.

The managers who prepare the statements may be honest, but they also have a stake in the result. A higher profit can mean a bigger bonus or an easier loan. Even honest people make mistakes. An audit gives the readers a second, independent pair of eyes.

What an audit is

A working definition: an audit is an independent examination of an entity’s financial statements and the records behind them, carried out by a qualified auditor, so that the auditor can give an opinion on whether the statements show a true and fair view. Each key word matters.

  • Independent. The auditor is not part of the management and has no personal interest in the result.
  • Examination. The auditor tests records, documents, assets and controls, and collects evidence.
  • Qualified. In India, the statutory audit of a company can be done only by a Chartered Accountant (CA), a member of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI), or by a firm of CAs.
  • Opinion. The auditor reports a professional judgement. It is not a certificate that every figure is perfect.

True and fair view is the standard the auditor reports against. It is not defined by a formula. Broadly, it means the statements are free from material errors, follow the applicable accounting framework (Indian Accounting Standards, Ind AS, or the older Accounting Standards, AS) and do not mislead the reader.

Audit is often confused with its neighbours, so keep them apart.

BookkeepingAccountingAuditing
Main workRecording transactions in the booksClassifying and summarising them into financial statementsExamining the statements and records and giving an opinion
Done byClerk or accounts assistantAccountant or finance teamIndependent auditor
OutputJournal and ledgersTrial balance and financial statementsAudit report

A loan application

Neha runs a packaged-foods unit in Karnal. Her accounts show a profit of ₹30 lakh, and she asks a bank for a working-capital loan. The bank asks for audited accounts. During the audit, the auditor attends the stock count and finds that the closing stock includes goods worth ₹3 lakh that had already been sold. Closing stock was overstated, so cost of goods sold was understated, and profit was overstated by exactly ₹3 lakh. The corrected profit is ₹30 lakh − ₹3 lakh = ₹27 lakh. The bank now relies on ₹27 lakh, the figure that survived independent checking.

What an audit can and cannot do

An audit gives reasonable assurance, which is a high level of assurance but not a guarantee. It cannot be absolute for good reasons. The auditor tests selected items rather than every transaction. Internal controls have limits. Many figures, such as provisions, depend on estimates. Evidence is usually persuasive rather than conclusive, and a determined fraud involving forged documents or collusion can be hard to see.

Two terms are important here. An error is an unintentional mistake, such as a wrong total. Fraud is an intentional act involving deception, such as inflating sales or hiding a liability. The management prepares the financial statements and is primarily responsible for preventing and detecting fraud. The auditor’s job is to give an opinion on the statements and to plan the audit so that material misstatements, whether from error or fraud, have a good chance of being found.

The gap between what the public expects from auditors (finding every fraud) and what an audit actually delivers is called the expectation gap. Understanding the real purpose of an audit is the first step in closing it.

Audit in Indian law

Every company in India, private or public, must appoint an auditor under the Companies Act, 2013. Other entities, such as co-operative societies, certain LLPs, trusts and businesses above prescribed turnover limits under the tax law, also need audits. Banks usually insist on audited accounts before lending even to small firms, so a first-time borrower often meets an auditor long before any law requires it.

Audit is not preparation

A common mistake is to think the auditor writes the accounts. The management prepares the financial statements. The auditor only examines them and reports. An auditor who prepares the accounts and then audits them would be checking their own work, which destroys independence.

Key points

  • An audit is an independent examination of financial statements by a qualified person, ending in a written opinion.
  • Users such as owners, lenders and regulators rely on audited accounts because managers have a stake in the results.
  • The opinion is about whether the statements give a true and fair view; it gives reasonable assurance, not a guarantee.
  • Management prepares the accounts and is mainly responsible for preventing fraud; the auditor examines and reports.