Skip to content
VJ Classes

One place to learn science, commerce, arts, computers and life skills

By the late nineteenth century governments were taking on railways, post offices, police forces, schools and taxes. Who should run all this, and how? Four thinkers gave the first systematic answers. Their ideas are called the classical theories because they treat an organisation as a well-designed machine.

Woodrow Wilson: politics and administration

Woodrow Wilson published “The Study of Administration” in 1887, years before he became the 28th President of the United States. He noticed that governments were growing so fast that, in his words, “it is getting to be harder to run a constitution than to frame one.” His answer was to study administration as a skill in its own right.

His central idea is the politics-administration dichotomy: politics decides what the government should do, and administration carries it out. “The field of administration is a field of business,” he wrote. Frank Goodnow (1900) made a similar split between the expression of the state’s will (politics) and its execution (administration). Wilson also said a country can learn good administrative methods from others without copying their politics.

Criticism. In real life the line is blurred. Civil servants advise ministers, draft rules and shape policy. Later writers such as Dwight Waldo (1948) and Paul Appleby (1949) showed that administration is deeply involved in politics.

Max Weber: the ideal bureaucracy

Max Weber (1864-1920), a German sociologist, asked why people obey officials. He named three kinds of legitimate authority: traditional (custom, such as a hereditary king), charismatic (the personal qualities of a leader) and legal-rational (belief in rules and law). Modern bureaucracy rests on the third.

Weber described an ideal type of bureaucracy with these features:

  1. Hierarchy: every office is under the control of a higher office.
  2. Specialisation: work is divided, and each office has defined duties.
  3. Written rules: actions follow general rules, not personal wishes.
  4. Impersonality: decisions are made “without anger or passion”, the same for everyone.
  5. Merit and career: officials are appointed for their qualifications and get a fixed salary, promotion and pension.
  6. Written records: decisions and orders are kept in files.
  7. Separation of office and person: the official does not own the post or its resources.

An ideal type is a pure model used to study real organisations. It does not mean “the best”. Weber thought bureaucracy was technically the most efficient form of organisation, but he also worried that it could trap people in rules.

Criticism. Robert Merton (1940) argued that strict rules can become ends in themselves, so officials follow the rule even when it defeats the purpose. This is called goal displacement; in daily speech it is “red tape”.

Taylor: scientific management

Frederick Winslow Taylor (1856-1915), an American engineer, wrote The Principles of Scientific Management (1911). He wanted to replace rule-of-thumb with science:

  • Study each job with time and motion study and find the “one best way”.
  • Select and train workers scientifically for each job.
  • Let managers plan the work and workers carry it out.
  • Pay incentives for output, and build co-operation between management and workers. Taylor called this a “mental revolution”.

He also proposed functional foremanship: eight specialist foremen instead of one all-purpose supervisor. Criticism: it treated workers like machines, ignored motivation and social needs, and broke the rule that a person should have one boss.

Henri Fayol: general management

Henri Fayol (1841-1925), a French mining engineer, wrote Administration industrielle et générale (1916). Taylor looked at the shop floor from below; Fayol looked at the whole organisation from the top. He listed five functions of management: planning, organising, commanding, co-ordinating and controlling. He also gave 14 principles, including division of work, authority and responsibility, discipline, unity of command (one person receives orders from one boss only), unity of direction, the scalar chain (the line of authority from top to bottom), initiative and esprit de corps. Fayol said the principles are flexible, not fixed laws.

Fayol’s gangplank lets two officers at the same level in different branches deal with each other directly, while telling their bosses, so work does not travel all the way up and down the chain.

ThinkerMain workCore ideaChief criticism
WilsonStudy of Administration (1887)Separate politics from administrationThe line is blurred in practice
WeberBureaucracy (ideal type)Rules, hierarchy, merit, impersonalityRed tape; rigid
TaylorScientific Management (1911)One best way; time and motion studyTreats workers as machines
FayolAdministration industrielle et générale (1916)Functions and 14 principles of managementPrinciples can conflict; too rigid

One application, four lenses

A citizen applies for a trade licence at a district office. Wilson: elected leaders set the licensing policy; the office only applies it. Weber: the file moves up fixed levels, follows written rules and is decided without favour. Taylor: measure how many days each step takes and remove the unnecessary ones. Fayol: each clerk has one boss, and officers of two branches may speak directly (gangplank) and inform their seniors.

The Indian file

Government of India offices follow a written system of “noting and drafting” laid down in the Central Secretariat Manual of Office Procedure. A dealing assistant writes a note, and the file moves up through the Section Officer, Under Secretary and higher officers, each recording a view. This is Weber’s hierarchy and written record at work.

Spot the broken principle

A clerk gets one order from the Section Officer and a different, conflicting order from the Deputy Secretary of another wing about the same task. Which of Fayol’s principles is broken?

Answer: unity of command. The clerk is receiving orders from two bosses.

“Ideal” does not mean “best”

Weber’s ideal type is a model that shows the pure features of bureaucracy. No real office matches it exactly, and Weber did not claim it was perfect.

Key points

  • Wilson (1887) separated politics (deciding) from administration (executing); later writers showed the line is blurred.
  • Weber’s ideal bureaucracy rests on legal-rational authority: hierarchy, specialisation, written rules, impersonality, merit and records.
  • Taylor’s scientific management looks for the one best way through time and motion study, but treats workers like machines.
  • Fayol listed five functions and 14 principles of management, such as unity of command and the scalar chain; the gangplank allows direct links across branches.