Skip to content
VJ Classes

One place to learn science, commerce, arts, computers and life skills

“That is just your opinion” ends many conversations. Philosophy begins where that sentence ends. An opinion is a claim. An argument is a claim together with the reasons offered for it. Opinions can only be agreed or disagreed with; arguments can be checked.

The parts of an argument

An argument has premises (the reasons) and a conclusion (the claim the reasons support). Words like because, since, given that usually introduce premises; therefore, so, hence introduce conclusions.

Putting an argument in standard form

“Online exams cannot be fair, since students at home can easily look up answers.”

  1. Students taking online exams at home can easily look up answers. (premise)
  2. An exam where some students can look up answers is not fair. (hidden premise)
  3. Therefore, online exams cannot be fair. (conclusion)

Writing it out reveals a hidden premise, and shows where to push back: perhaps not all online exams are taken at home, or perhaps open-book exams can be fair if everyone can look things up.

Valid and sound

An argument is valid when the conclusion must be true if the premises are true. It is sound when it is valid and its premises really are true.

  • “All metals conduct electricity. Copper is a metal. So copper conducts electricity.” Valid and sound.
  • “All birds can fly. Penguins are birds. So penguins can fly.” Valid, but not sound: the first premise is false.
  • “Some students are athletes. Ravi is a student. So Ravi is an athlete.” Invalid: the premises could be true and the conclusion false.

Validity is about the form of the reasoning; soundness also needs the facts to be right. To reject a conclusion fairly, you must show either a false premise or an invalid step.

The Indian five-step argument

The Nyaya school, which we study in detail later, set out a public argument in five steps, designed for debate:

  1. Pratijna (thesis): The hill has fire.
  2. Hetu (reason): Because it has smoke.
  3. Udaharana (example with a general rule): Wherever there is smoke, there is fire, as in a kitchen.
  4. Upanaya (application): This hill has smoke of that kind.
  5. Nigamana (conclusion): Therefore, the hill has fire.

Notice step 3: it states the general rule and gives an example. Nyaya insisted that a reason is only good if the connection between reason and conclusion is shown, not merely asserted.

Arguing fairly

Good philosophers follow the principle of charity: before criticising an argument, state it in its strongest form, the version its supporters would accept. Attacking a weak version that nobody holds is the straw man fallacy. Attacking the person instead of the argument is the ad hominem fallacy. Offering only two options when there are more is a false dilemma.

Common mistake

Thinking that a conclusion is false because the argument for it is bad. A bad argument only shows that this argument fails; the conclusion might still be true for other reasons.

Try this

Take a newspaper editorial. Find its main conclusion and write its argument in numbered premises. Mark any hidden premise. Then write the strongest objection you can.

Key points

  • An argument is a conclusion plus the premises that support it.
  • Valid: the conclusion follows. Sound: valid with true premises.
  • The Nyaya five-step argument makes the general rule and an example explicit.
  • Be charitable: criticise the strongest version of a view.