Skip to content
VJ Classes

One place to learn science, commerce, arts, computers and life skills

Insurance is a promise made today and tested years later, often when someone is in distress. Six principles keep that promise fair.

Honesty and interest

1. Utmost good faith. In most shopping, the rule is “buyer beware”. In insurance, the person applying (the proposer) knows the truth about their health, habits, vehicle or property, and the insurer does not. So both sides must be completely honest. The proposer must disclose every material fact: any fact that would influence the insurer’s decision to accept the risk or to fix the premium. Smoking, diabetes, an earlier surgery and a refused proposal are examples. The insurer must also explain the terms honestly.

If a material fact is hidden or stated wrongly, the insurer can reject a claim or cancel the policy. For life insurance, Section 45 of the Insurance Act, 1938 sets a limit: a policy can be questioned for mis-statement, suppression or fraud only within three years of the date it was issued, started or revived (whichever is latest), and the insurer must give its grounds in writing. After three years, a life policy cannot be called in question on any ground.

“Do not write that on the form”

A seller says, “Do not mention your smoking, it will only raise the premium.” You sign the proposal form, so the answers are yours, whoever filled them in. If the truth emerges at claim time, your family can lose the money. Read the form before signing.

2. Insurable interest. You have insurable interest when you would suffer a financial loss if the insured thing were damaged or the insured person died. Without this rule, insurance would be a bet, and it would tempt people to harm others. You have it in your own life, your home and car, your spouse, children and parents (close family, because of dependence), a borrower’s life up to the amount lent, and a key employee’s life if you run the business. You do not have it in a neighbour’s house or a stranger’s life.

When must it exist? In life insurance, at the time the policy is taken. In property and other general insurance, at the time of the loss. Someone who has sold a car cannot claim for it later.

Money: indemnity, contribution and subrogation

3. Indemnity. The insurer should put you back in the financial position you were in just before the loss: no better, no worse. So the payment is the actual loss or the sum insured, whichever is lower. Property, motor and most health-reimbursement policies work this way.

Life insurance is different

A human life cannot be valued in rupees, so life insurance is not a contract of indemnity. The insurer pays the agreed sum assured. Fixed-benefit health plans, such as hospital cash or a critical-illness lump sum, also pay a set amount whatever the bill.

Indemnity has a consequence for people who insure for too little. Many property policies contain an average clause: if the sum insured is lower than the real value, the claim is cut in the same proportion.

The average clause

Neha’s shop stock is worth ₹10 lakh, but she insures it for ₹5 lakh. A fire destroys stock worth ₹2 lakh.

Claim = loss × (sum insured ÷ value) = ₹2 lakh × (5 ÷ 10) = ₹1 lakh.

She bears half of her own loss because she was under-insured.

4. Contribution. If the same risk is insured with two or more insurers (double insurance), you cannot collect the full loss from each. Your total recovery cannot exceed the actual loss, and each insurer pays its rateable share.

Share of an insurer = loss × (its sum insured ÷ total of all sums insured)

Two policies, one loss

A shop’s contents are insured with Insurer A for ₹4 lakh and with Insurer B for ₹6 lakh. A fire causes a loss of ₹5 lakh.

  • A pays ₹5 lakh × 4 ÷ 10 = ₹2 lakh.
  • B pays ₹5 lakh × 6 ÷ 10 = ₹3 lakh.

The total is ₹5 lakh, exactly the loss.

5. Subrogation. After paying a claim, the insurer steps into your shoes and may recover the money from whoever caused the loss. If a truck driver damages Anita’s parked car and her insurer pays ₹80,000 for the repair, the insurer can then recover that amount from the truck owner or the truck’s insurer. Anita must not waive her right against the wrongdoer, and she cannot keep both payments. Contribution and subrogation both follow from indemnity, so they apply only to indemnity contracts.

The cause of the loss

6. Proximate cause. The proximate cause is the dominant, effective cause of a loss: the cause that sets the chain of events moving, not a remote one. If the proximate cause is an insured peril, the insurer pays. If it is an excluded peril, the insurer does not.

An unbroken chain

A personal accident policy covers death caused by an accident. Ramesh slips on a wet floor and breaks his thigh bone. In hospital the wound becomes infected and he dies a week later. The chain from the fall to the death is unbroken, so the proximate cause is the accident, an insured peril. Had he died of an unrelated heart attack, the chain would be broken and the claim would fail.

Key points

  • Utmost good faith means both sides disclose everything material; under Section 45, a life insurer can question a policy only within three years.
  • Insurable interest means a real financial stake: at the time of buying in life insurance, at the time of loss in property insurance.
  • Indemnity restores the loss without profit; under-insurance can trigger an average clause that reduces the claim.
  • Contribution splits one loss among several insurers by sums insured; subrogation lets the insurer recover from the wrongdoer.
  • The proximate cause, the dominant cause of the loss, decides whether a claim is covered.