Skip to content
VJ Classes

One place to learn science, commerce, arts, computers and life skills

Does a child learn by being told, or by finding out?

Show a five-year-old two equal balls of clay. Roll one into a long sausage and ask, “Which has more clay?” Many five-year-olds point to the sausage. An eight-year-old says, “Same. You only changed the shape.” The younger child is not careless; her mind works in a different way. Jean Piaget built a famous theory on such observations, and Lev Vygotsky added a social view. Together they form the base of constructivism.

Piaget: the child as a young scientist

Jean Piaget (1896-1980), a Swiss psychologist, argued that children construct knowledge by acting on the world, not by simply absorbing facts. His key terms:

  • Schema: a mental pattern for understanding or acting, such as a child’s idea of “dog”.
  • Assimilation: fitting a new experience into an existing schema (a child calls a goat a “dog”).
  • Accommodation: changing the schema because it does not fit (“No, goats have horns; this is a new animal”).
  • Equilibration: the drive for mental balance. A puzzling experience creates imbalance, and assimilation and accommodation restore balance at a higher level. This is how thinking grows.

Piaget described four stages that always come in the same order:

StageApproximate ageMain features
SensorimotorBirth to 2 yearsLearns through senses and actions; develops object permanence (knowing a hidden object still exists)
Preoperational2 to 7 yearsLanguage and pretend play; egocentric (finds it hard to see another person’s view); animism (thinks objects are alive); fails conservation tasks
Concrete operational7 to 11 yearsLogical thinking about real objects; conservation, reversibility, classification
Formal operational11 years onwardsAbstract and hypothetical reasoning; systematic problem solving

Conservation means knowing that a quantity stays the same when only its shape or arrangement changes. The clay task above tests it. The ages are approximate, and children differ, but Piaget held that the order does not change.

Classroom meaning: respect readiness; use concrete material (beads, fraction strips, real leaves) in primary classes; let children discover; accept errors as thinking in progress; expect different children to move at different speeds. Later research suggests that young children can do more than Piaget found and that development is more gradual and more shaped by culture than his stages suggest.

Vygotsky: learning is social

Lev Vygotsky (1896-1934), a Soviet psychologist, believed that thinking first appears between people and only later inside the child. Language, stories and tools of a culture shape how a child thinks. Children talk aloud to themselves while solving problems (private speech); Vygotsky saw this as a tool for thought that later becomes silent inner speech.

His central idea is the zone of proximal development (ZPD): the gap between what a learner can do alone and what the learner can do with help from a more knowledgeable other (MKO) such as a teacher, parent or older child. Teaching works best inside this zone, because tasks that are too easy bore the child and tasks that are too hard defeat the child. The help given is called scaffolding (a term from Wood, Bruner and Ross, 1976): support that is given at the start and then slowly removed, like the bamboo scaffolding around a building under construction.

Scaffolding a Class 4 maths problem

Meena cannot solve 46 + 38 alone, but she can solve it with help. The teacher first asks, “What are the ones digits?” (hint). Then she suggests using a place-value chart (tool). Next time she only says, “Remember the chart.” On the fifth day Meena solves a new sum alone. The ZPD has moved forward.

Constructivism in the classroom

Constructivism says learners actively build knowledge on what they already know, instead of receiving it ready-made. The teacher becomes a facilitator: one who asks good questions, arranges experiences and gives support. Children’s prior ideas, including wrong ideas (misconceptions), are the starting point. Jerome Bruner, another constructivist, stressed discovery learning and the spiral curriculum, in which a topic returns again and again at greater depth.

PointPiagetVygotsky
Main ideaChild explores alone and builds schemasChild learns through social interaction and culture
Learning and developmentDevelopment must be ready firstLearning leads development inside the ZPD
LanguageReflects thinkingShapes thinking
TeacherArranges experiences for discoveryGuides and scaffolds as a partner
ClassroomHands-on activitiesGroup work, peer help, guided talk

NCF 2005

India’s National Curriculum Framework 2005 asked schools to move away from rote learning and to treat children as active makers of knowledge. Activity-based NCERT textbooks reflect this constructivist view.

Which theorist?

(a) A teacher gives a child a hint, then removes it. (b) A child resists the idea that a tomato is a fruit because “fruits are sweet”. (c) Children discuss in groups and correct each other.

Answers: (a) Vygotsky (scaffolding); (b) Piaget (a schema that must accommodate); (c) Vygotsky (social learning).

Key points

  • Piaget: children build knowledge through assimilation, accommodation and equilibration, in four stages: sensorimotor, preoperational, concrete operational, formal operational.
  • Vygotsky: learning is social; the ZPD is the gap between independent and assisted performance, and scaffolding is temporary help.
  • Constructivism makes the learner active and the teacher a facilitator who starts from prior knowledge.
  • Use concrete material for young children and group talk and guided help for all.