Academic texts are not stories. They are arguments: an author wants to convince you of something and gives reasons. Reading well means finding that argument quickly and judging it fairly.
First, survey
Before reading closely, spend two or three minutes on a quick survey:
- Read the title, abstract or introduction, and the conclusion.
- Look at headings, figures and tables.
- Ask: What question is this text answering? What seems to be its answer?
This prepares your mind, so the details have somewhere to go.
Then, read for four things
- The thesis: the main claim. It is often near the end of the introduction, and repeated in the conclusion.
- The reasons: why the author thinks the thesis is true.
- The evidence: data, examples, quotations or studies offered in support.
- The counter-arguments: objections the author considers and answers.
Signpost words show you how a text is built: however, in contrast (a turn); therefore, thus (a conclusion); for example, for instance (evidence); moreover, furthermore (an added reason); admittedly, it may be argued (a counter-argument).
Annotate as you go
Use a simple, consistent system in the margin: T for thesis, R for reason, E for evidence, ? for anything unclear, ! for anything you disagree with. Underline sparingly: if everything is underlined, nothing stands out.
Finding the argument
Passage: “Many schools have banned mobile phones in classrooms. However, the evidence for this is mixed. Some studies find small gains in test scores after bans, particularly for weaker students, while others find no effect. Moreover, phones can support learning when teachers use them deliberately. Schools should therefore regulate phone use rather than ban it outright.”
- Thesis: schools should regulate phone use rather than ban it.
- Reason 1: the evidence for bans is mixed. Evidence: studies with different results.
- Reason 2: phones can support learning when used deliberately.
- Signposts: however (turn against the common view), moreover (added reason), therefore (conclusion).
Read critically, not cynically
Critical reading does not mean finding fault with everything. It means asking: Is the evidence enough? Is it relevant? Has the author considered the obvious objection? Are any words used vaguely? Then giving credit where the argument is strong.
Try this
Take one editorial from a national newspaper. Annotate it with T, R, E and ?. Then write the argument in four lines: thesis, two reasons, one piece of evidence.
Key points
- Survey before you read: title, introduction, conclusion, headings.
- Read for thesis, reasons, evidence and counter-arguments.
- Signpost words reveal the structure of the argument.
- Critical reading weighs strengths as well as weaknesses.