Four quick checks that work on news, advertisements, debates and exam passages.
Most arguments we meet are short: a headline, a forward, a debate point. You do not need a logic course to test them, only four questions asked in order.
1. What exactly is the claim?
Write it in one sentence. Many arguments fall apart here, because the claim keeps changing — from "this policy failed" to "the people behind it are bad".
2. What reasons are given?
List them. If there are none, it is an opinion, not an argument. If the "reason" is that many people believe it, or that a famous person said it, that is not evidence about the claim itself.
3. If the reasons were true, would the claim follow?
This is the key test. "Two of my friends got jobs after this course, so it guarantees a job" — even if both friends did get jobs, the conclusion is far bigger than the evidence. That is a hasty generalisation.
4. What is being assumed?
Every argument rests on unstated assumptions. "We must ban phones in college or students will fail" assumes there are only two options. Spot the hidden step and ask whether it is true.
The usual suspects
- Attacking the person instead of the point.
- False choice: presenting two options when there are more.
- Slippery slope: claiming one step must lead to disaster, without showing why.
- Appeal to authority outside the authority's field.
Practise on one argument a day. Our free Critical Thinking course turns these checks into a habit.